How to Prepare for a Difficult 1:1 With an Underperforming Employee (in 10 Minutes)

You have ten minutes before the meeting. Here is what to write down, how to open, what to ask, and how to end with something both of you can check next week.

Greg Swierad

Short answer: in ten minutes, write down one specific recent example of the gap, its impact, and what good looks like. In the meeting, say the purpose in the first minute, describe the example without labels, ask before you diagnose, and end with one agreed next step and a date. Write that step down where you'll both see it.

The 10-minute preparation

Minutes 1–4: the facts

On paper or in a note, write:

  • Example: one or two specific, recent, observable things. "The Q3 report came in three days late and had the wrong customer numbers" is usable; "you're not committed" is not.
  • Impact: what happened because of it. Who waited, what had to be redone, what the client said.
  • What good looks like: the standard, stated so you could check it next week.

This is close to the SBI model (Situation, Behaviour, Impact) from the Center for Creative Leadership; more on it in How to give feedback your team can use.

Minutes 5–7: the questions

Prepare two or three open questions. You don't yet know why it happened, and the reason changes what you should do. Unclear expectations, missing skill, too much work, a problem outside work and low motivation each need a different response.

  • "How do you see the last few weeks?"
  • "What got in the way on the report?"
  • "What would help you hit the deadline next time?"

Minutes 8–10: your opening and your ending

Write your first two sentences, so you don't soften them into nothing. For example: "I want to talk about the last two reports. They were late and the client noticed, and I want us to fix that together." Then write what a good outcome of the meeting is: usually one concrete next step, who does what, and when you'll check in.

In the meeting

  1. Purpose first. No long small talk; it makes the real topic land harder.
  2. Example and impact, once, calmly.
  3. Ask, then listen. Aim to talk less than half the time.
  4. Agree on the standard and check that it's understood the same way.
  5. One next step, with a date. If it's a bigger issue, a short plan with a check-in every week.
  6. Close with support: what you will do (remove a blocker, clarify priorities).

Common mistakes

MistakeInstead
Feedback sandwich (praise, criticism, praise)Be direct about the issue; give genuine praise at another time
Labels: "careless", "not a team player"Observable behaviour and its impact
Ten issues at onceOne or two, the most important
Ending without an agreementOne step, an owner, a date
Never following upPut the check-in in your calendar before you leave the room

Using an app to prepare

This is the exact situation we built Mentorist's mentor for, so take this as the maker's description. You type the situation ("my senior designer has missed three deadlines, she's usually great, 1:1 in ten minutes"), and the mentor helps you prepare along the lines above, with answers grounded in management books: how to open, which questions to ask, what to agree on. Because it remembers your context, you can tell it afterwards how the conversation went and it will bring up the agreed step later. A general chatbot can help too if you give it the context; see Mentorist vs ChatGPT.

Related: Your first 90 days as a new manager · Best apps for new managers

Frequently asked questions

I have a difficult 1:1 with an underperforming employee in 10 minutes. What do I do?

Write down three things: one specific, recent example of the problem; its impact on the team or customer; and what good looks like. Open by saying why you are meeting, describe the example without labels, ask what is going on from their side, and end with one agreed next step and a date to check in.

How do I start a conversation about poor performance?

Say the purpose in the first minute, calmly and plainly, for example: I want to talk about the last two reports, because they came in late and the client noticed. Then pause and let them respond. Long warm-up small talk makes the real topic land harder.

What should I avoid saying?

Labels and generalisations (you are careless, you always), comparisons with colleagues, and a list of ten issues at once. Stick to one or two observable examples and their impact.

What if the employee gets defensive or upset?

Slow down, acknowledge the emotion, and come back to the specific example and the shared goal. It is fine to pause the meeting and continue the next day; it is not fine to drop the topic.

Is there an app that helps me prepare for conversations like this?

Mentorist's AI mentor lets you describe the situation and helps you plan how to open, what to ask and what to agree on, grounded in management books; it remembers the conversation so it can ask afterwards how it went. You can also use the checklist on this page on paper.

When should I involve HR?

Follow your company's policy. Involve HR early if the issue is conduct rather than performance, if there may be a health or legal dimension, or if earlier conversations and agreed steps have not worked.

Start Your Growth Journey

Download Mentorist and transform knowledge into action