Short answer: describe the Situation, the Behaviour you saw and its Impact (the SBI model), then ask a question and agree what happens next. Do it soon after the event, in private if it's critical, and give positive feedback often. Kim Scott's Radical Candor adds the attitude: care personally and challenge directly.
Two frameworks in one table
| SBI (Situation–Behaviour–Impact) | Radical Candor | |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Center for Creative Leadership | Kim Scott, Radical Candor |
| What it gives you | The structure of a single piece of feedback | The attitude and relationship behind feedback |
| Core idea | Be specific: when, what you saw, what it caused | Care personally and challenge directly at the same time |
| Use it for | Preparing what to say | Checking how you say it, and whether you say it at all |
SBI with examples
| Vague feedback | SBI version |
|---|---|
| "Great job on the presentation." | "In Tuesday's client call (S), you opened with the three numbers they cared about (B). They stopped checking their phones and asked about next steps (I)." |
| "You need to be more on top of things." | "In this week's stand-ups (S), the API task was 'almost done' three days in a row (B). The mobile team couldn't plan their sprint (I). What's blocking it?" |
| "You're too negative in meetings." | "In the planning meeting (S), you said 'that will never work' about two proposals before they were finished (B). Two people stopped contributing (I)." |
A simple script for critical feedback
- Ask for the moment: "Do you have five minutes? I want to give you some feedback on yesterday's meeting."
- SBI, in two or three sentences.
- Ask: "How did you see it?" Then listen.
- Agree on what's next: one change, and when you'll talk again.
Five rules that matter more than the framework
- Soon. Feedback a month later is about a memory, not a behaviour.
- Private for critical, public for praise, unless the person prefers otherwise; ask them in a 1:1.
- Behaviour, not character. "You interrupted twice", not "you're rude".
- One thing at a time.
- More positive than critical, and both sincere.
How to practise
For one week, give one piece of specific positive feedback every day using SBI. It's low-risk, people notice, and it builds the trust that makes critical feedback land. When you need to give harder feedback, prepare it: write the SBI on paper, or talk it through with someone. Mentorist's AI mentor (our app) can help you prepare it from management books and will ask afterwards how it went. For a performance conversation specifically, see how to prepare for a difficult 1:1.
Related: Your first 90 days as a new manager · Learn leadership in 10 minutes a day