Mentorist vs Asking ChatGPT for Advice

A general chatbot can answer almost any question about leading a team. So why use a mentor app? Where each one is the better tool.

Greg Swierad

Short answer: ChatGPT is more flexible and can be free, but it answers from its general training (and web search, if enabled) and leaves the plan and follow-up to you. Mentorist's answers are grounded in the ideas of 700+ non-fiction books; turns one idea a day into a concrete step, and its mentor remembers your goals and what you committed to and asks how it went. Use a chatbot for open questions; use a mentor app when you want to change a behaviour over weeks.

Disclosure: I'm the founder of Mentorist. I use general chatbots every day too; this is about which tool fits which job.

Side by side

General chatbot (ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude)Mentorist
Where answers come fromThe model's training and, often, a web searchGrounded in the ideas of 700+ non-fiction books
StructureNone by default; you ask, it answersOne idea a day: 3–5 minute insight, a "do this now" action, a 2-minute fallback
Follow-upOnly if you come back and askThe mentor remembers your commitments and asks how it went
MemoryMemory features, depending on plan, region and settingsKeeps your goals and context as part of the product
ScopeAnythingLeadership, management, productivity, communication, psychology, money, health, relationships, parenting
PriceFree plans; paid plans (e.g. Claude Pro $20/mo)Free version; with AI mentor $39.99/mo or $189/yr (US App Store), 7-day trial if eligible

Where a general chatbot wins

  • Range. It can help with your strategy deck, your Excel formula and your feedback e-mail in the same conversation.
  • Current information. With web search it can find this week's news; a book library cannot.
  • Price. There are free plans.

Where a mentor app wins

  • Advice grounded in books. When you ask how to handle an underperforming employee, the answer draws on well-known management books, so you can look up where an idea comes from.
  • A routine. Change comes from small actions repeated, not from one great answer. The daily step is built in.
  • Someone who asks. If on Monday you planned to delegate the weekly report, the mentor remembers it and follows up on whether you did.

If you use ChatGPT as a mentor, do this

  1. Start with context: your role, your team, the situation, what you've tried.
  2. Ask for options with the book or framework each comes from, so you can check them.
  3. End every conversation with one action, a date and a trigger ("When the 1:1 starts, I will…").
  4. Come back afterwards and report. That's the part a mentor app does for you.

Related: Can an AI chatbot be a good mentor or coach? · Best AI coach apps · Preparing for a difficult 1:1

Frequently asked questions

Is Mentorist just ChatGPT with books?

No. Mentorist's mentor is grounded in the ideas of 700+ non-fiction books, and the app is built around a routine: one idea a day as a concrete action, plus a mentor that remembers your goals and commitments and follows up. A general chatbot is a blank page you have to structure yourself.

Can I use ChatGPT as a mentor?

Yes. It can be very helpful for thinking through a situation. To make it work as a mentor, give it your context, ask it to cite which book or framework an idea comes from, write down one action, and come back to report how it went.

Which is cheaper?

A general chatbot can be free. Mentorist has a free version with a daily free book and a few mentor messages; the plan with unlimited mentor conversations is $39.99 a month or $189 a year on the US App Store (November 2026).

Does ChatGPT remember previous conversations?

ChatGPT has memory features that can save details and reference past chats, depending on your plan and region and your settings. Mentorist's mentor is designed to keep track of your goals and the commitments you made, and to bring them up later.

When is a general chatbot the better choice?

When your question is outside self-development and leadership, when you need current information from the web, or when you want to draft and edit text. Mentorist is narrower on purpose.

Start Your Growth Journey

Download Mentorist and transform knowledge into action