Short answer: take one idea from the book, turn it into an if-then plan for a specific situation you will face this week ("When my 1:1 with Anna starts, I will ask one open question before I give my view"), make the first version tiny, and check after a few days whether you did it. Reading the next book before you have used anything from the last one is a common reason nothing changes.
I used to read a self-help book a week and apply almost nothing. I wrote about that years ago in Reading 52 books a year will not change your life. The problem was never a lack of good ideas. It was that every new book replaced the last one before anything had a chance to become a habit. What follows is the method I wish I had used then, and the one we built Mentorist around.
Why ideas from books do not stick
Three things work against you.
- Forgetting. Anything you do not recall or use fades fast. Highlighting and re-reading feel productive, but research on learning consistently finds that recalling an idea from memory does more than reading it again.
- Vague intentions. "I should delegate more" has no time, place or first move, so it never competes with the urgent thing in front of you.
- Too many ideas at once. A good management book contains twenty practices. Trying five of them on Monday means none of them survives Thursday.
The method: one idea, one situation, one small step
1. Choose one idea that fits your week
Do not pick the most impressive idea. Pick the one that fits a situation you already know is coming: a 1:1, a planning meeting, a hard conversation at home, the hour after lunch when you procrastinate. An idea attached to a real situation has a chance; an idea attached to "someday" does not.
2. Write it as an if-then plan
Psychologist Peter Gollwitzer called these implementation intentions: "When X happens, I will do Y." Across many studies, people who make such plans follow through more often than people who only set a goal. The trigger does the remembering for you.
| Idea from the book | Vague intention | If-then plan |
|---|---|---|
| Ask more, tell less (coaching habit) | "Be more of a coach" | When a team member brings me a problem, I will ask "What have you tried so far?" before suggesting anything. |
| Deep work blocks | "Focus more" | When I sit down at 9:00 on Tuesday and Thursday, I will close chat and e-mail for 60 minutes. |
| Habit stacking | "Read every day" | After I pour my morning coffee, I will read one page. |
| Specific feedback | "Give more feedback" | When the Friday stand-up ends, I will tell one person one concrete thing they did well and why it mattered. |
3. Make the first version tiny
The version you will do on a bad day is the one that builds the habit. BJ Fogg (Tiny Habits) and James Clear (Atomic Habits, the "two-minute rule") make the same point from different angles: start with something so small that skipping it feels silly, then grow it. One open question in a meeting, not a new meeting culture.
4. Recall it, do not re-read it
Before the situation, ask yourself what the idea was and what you planned to do, without looking at your notes. That small act of retrieval is what strengthens the memory, and it doubles as a rehearsal.
5. Review after a few days
Three questions: Did I do it? What happened? Keep, adjust or drop? This is where most people stop, and it is the step that turns an experiment into a habit or frees you to try the next idea. A review that someone else asks for (a colleague, a coach, a mentor) often works better than one you promise yourself.
Tools that help, and what each one does
| Tool | Helps with | Leaves to you |
|---|---|---|
| Paper notebook or notes app | Writing the if-then plan, reviewing it | Remembering to look at it |
| Calendar | Putting the trigger and the review on a date | Choosing the idea, the reflection |
| Book summary apps (Blinkist, Headway, Shortform…) | Finding which book and idea is worth your time | Turning the idea into an action |
| A colleague, coach or mentor | Accountability, perspective on your situation | Availability, cost |
| Mentorist | One small step a day from a book, a mentor chat that knows your situation and follows up | Doing the step |
Mentorist is our app, so take this paragraph as the maker's description, not a review. It turns ideas from 700+ non-fiction books into one concrete step a day: a 3–5 minute insight you read or listen to, a "do this now" action, and a 2-minute fallback for busy days. You can ask the AI mentor about your real situation; it answers from the books, remembers your goals and what you said you would do, and asks how it went. It covers steps 1, 3 and 5 for you: one idea, a small action, and a mentor that follows up. If you prefer a notebook, the method works just as well on paper.
A one-week example
- Monday: from The Coaching Habit you take one idea, ask before you advise. Plan: "When someone brings me a problem, my first sentence is a question."
- Tuesday–Thursday: you try it in two conversations. Once you forget and jump straight to the answer.
- Friday: review. It worked in a 1:1, it felt awkward in a group meeting. Keep it for 1:1s, drop it for meetings for now.
- Next week: same idea, one more situation, or the next idea.
Related: How to learn leadership in 10 minutes a day · Can an AI chatbot be a good mentor or coach? · Best Blinkist alternatives for people who want to act on what they read