Coach with questions so people solve their own problems

Medium - Requires some preparation Recommended

When someone brings you a tangled problem, your first urge might be to fix it. Resist. Shift from answer-giver to question coach. Start with facts: “What happened that we could film?” Then set the aim: “What would you like to be happening instead?” Without a target, there’s nothing to steer toward. The person will likely pause, look at the floor, and think harder than usual. That’s good.

Next, list options. Don’t judge yet, just get A, B, C on paper. Now stress-test each against the desired state. “If we do A, will the result actually match what we want?” Most options will fall away. I once watched a new team lead do this. He sketched three fixes on a whiteboard, then crossed two with a squeak of the marker when he saw they wouldn’t get him there.

A plan clicks when option pieces line up with the outcome. Add owners and time. Keep it in plain words, not jargon. Then, reflect capability: “You’re good at diagnosing. You just did it. Run this and check back tomorrow.” The person often leaves taller. I might be wrong, but I’ve rarely seen someone forget a plan they wrote themselves.

This sequence leverages cognitive ownership and implementation intentions. People are more committed to solutions they generate, and they act more when “what” is tied to “when and where.” It also reduces learned helplessness by making change feel doable. Your role is a mirror and a map, not a mechanic.

When a colleague brings you a problem, ask them to describe the behavior you’d see on video, then ask what they want to be happening instead so you’ve got a real target. Generate a few options on paper and test each one against that target, discarding anything that won’t actually get the result, then assemble a simple sequence with owners and timelines. Close by naming the strengths they showed in the conversation so they leave believing they can execute. Use this the very next time someone says, “Got a minute?”

What You'll Achieve

Internally, grow confidence and ownership by guiding people to define outcomes and choose actions. Externally, see faster, more durable fixes because solutions are tested against clear ends and owned by the doer.

Run the outcome-based question sequence

1

Ask for the problem in behavioral terms

“What exactly happened that we can observe?” Cut out labels and feelings, stick to facts.

2

Define the desired state clearly

“What would you like to be happening instead?” Without a target, it’s just a complaint.

3

Generate options and test against the desired state

List A, B, C, then ask, “If we do this, will we actually get what we want?” Discard weak options.

4

Sequence a plan you believe in

Combine steps if needed, assign owners and timelines, and write it down.

5

Reflect capability back to them

Name why they can do it. Confidence grows when people hear their competence recognized.

Reflection Questions

  • Where do you tend to jump in with answers, and what question could you ask instead?
  • How will you keep discussions in behavioral terms and out of labels?
  • What phrase will you use to reflect capability without empty flattery?
  • Which recurring problem needs this sequence today?

Personalization Tips

  • Education: A teacher guides a student from “the lab was confusing” to “I want to isolate variables; I’ll rerun steps 3–4 with fresh samples tomorrow.”
  • Home: A parent helps a teen move from “my room is a mess” to “by 6 pm I’ll sort clothes, bag trash, and clear the desk.”
The One Minute Manager
← Back to Book

The One Minute Manager

Kenneth H. Blanchard, Spencer Johnson 1981
Insight 5 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.