A failed rescue mission still kept hundreds of prisoners alive for years

Medium - Requires some preparation

It's tempting to treat hope as a pleasant feeling you either have or don't, something closer to optimism or luck than to anything you can actually build. Admiral William H. McRaven's own experience argues against that. In 2011, while serving in Afghanistan, he was told by video call that a bone marrow biopsy had found chronic lymphocytic leukemia in his spleen, and that his military career was likely over. He flew home braced for the worst. Then he sat across from a specialist, Dr. Michael Keating, who walked in, demanded a hug, told McRaven's wife she could stop looking for a new boyfriend, and calmly explained that newer treatments meant the spleen removal and immediate chemotherapy McRaven had been told to expect weren't necessary at all. McRaven asked if he could go back to Afghanistan. Sure, Keating said. Just try not to get shot.

McRaven's diagnosis hadn't changed in that room. What changed was his sense of what tomorrow might hold, and he says that shift let him keep working for years afterward instead of spending them consumed by fear.

He draws a similar lesson from a very different story: a 1970 Green Beret raid deep into North Vietnam to rescue American POWs from a camp called Son Tay. The camp turned out to be empty, the prisoners moved months earlier, and the raid looked like a total failure. It wasn't until the POWs came home in 1973 that anyone learned what the raid had actually done. We knew we hadn't been forgotten, one of them said. The attempt itself, not its success, was what had kept hundreds of imprisoned men believing they could survive.

McRaven's point is that hope is not a mood, it's a specific belief that tomorrow will be better than today, and that belief only holds up if it's backed by someone credible enough to make it plausible. That means hope isn't only something you receive. He argues each person has some particular skill, steadiness, or knowledge that someone else currently lacks, and giving that thing to another person, deliberately, is what actually makes their tomorrow more believable.

Think of one person in your life right now who is bracing for a bad outcome, and identify the one specific thing you are genuinely good at, whether it's staying calm under pressure, explaining complicated information simply, or just showing up reliably, that could make their tomorrow feel more believable to them. Offer that specific thing directly this week rather than a vague reassurance, the way a doctor's plain explanation or a failed rescue attempt still gave people something concrete to hold onto. Keep your promise small enough that you can actually deliver on it, since hope collapses fast once it's shown to be empty. Then check back with that person again, more than once, because hope tends to need renewing rather than delivering just the one time.

What You'll Achieve

The listener stops treating hope as a vague feeling to offer others and instead learns to give something specific and deliverable, drawn from their own particular strengths, that makes another person's difficult tomorrow feel genuinely more survivable.

How to give someone real, deliverable hope

1

*Identify someone bracing for bad news.*

Think of a specific person currently facing an uncertain or frightening outcome.

2

*Name your specific, deliverable strength.*

Identify one concrete thing you are genuinely good at that this person currently lacks, rather than a generic offer to help.

3

*Offer it directly and make it small enough to deliver.*

Give something specific and realistic rather than a vague reassurance, since an empty promise damages hope rather than building it.

4

*Check back more than once.*

Renew the offer of support over time rather than treating one gesture as sufficient.

Reflection Questions

  • What specific skill or strength do you have that someone close to you currently lacks and badly needs right now?
  • Have you ever given someone vague reassurance instead of something concrete, and did it actually help?
  • Who gave you a piece of real, deliverable hope during your own hardest stretch, and what exactly did they give you?

Personalization Tips

  • A financially literate friend offers to sit down and actually go through someone's bills with them, rather than just saying it'll work out.
  • A colleague who is calm under deadline pressure offers to co-write the first draft with a panicked teammate instead of just telling them not to worry.
The Hero Code: Lessons Learned from Lives Well Lived
← Back to Book

The Hero Code: Lessons Learned from Lives Well Lived

William H. McRaven • 2021
Insight 8 of 10

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.