What a strained back finally taught her about money and happiness

Hard - Requires significant effort

Gretchen Rubin threw out her back leaning over her daughter's crib the wrong way, and for almost a month she could barely sit, type, or sleep. Her father-in-law suggested physical therapy. She kept insisting it would get better on its own, until one night, struggling to turn over in bed, she finally called for an appointment. Two visits later, the pain was gone, and the very next day, she noticed something: she'd already stopped thinking about her back at all.

That moment became what she called the Epiphany of the Back Spasm, and it gave her a way to finally make sense of a question that had been frustrating her for the whole month she'd spent researching money: does it buy happiness, or doesn't it. Money, she concluded, doesn't buy happiness the way good health doesn't buy happiness. When either one is a problem, you can think of little else. When it isn't a problem, you barely think about it at all. Neither one guarantees happiness on its own, since plenty of healthy, wealthy people are miserable, but the absence of either one reliably produces suffering. Research she cited backed this up in a specific way: people with higher incomes report being happier more often than people with lower incomes, but the effect works mainly by removing the feeling bad that comes from financial anxiety, job insecurity, and boring, tiring chores, not by directly manufacturing joy.

Once she reframed it this way, she stopped feeling vaguely guilty about spending and started spending on purpose: an expensive strength-training gym membership because her long-term health mattered to her, professional photographs of her children because vivid memories mattered to her, a good blender because she used it daily. She also noticed her own pattern of underbuying, delaying purchases like saline solution or a winter coat until she was already desperate, and decided to buy needful things ahead of need instead, which, paradoxically, meant fewer trips to the store, not more. And she adopted one more habit that felt almost the opposite of frugality: spending out, actually using the good stationery, the nice pen, rather than saving it indefinitely for an occasion that might never come, inspired by a bottle of her grandmother's perfume she found unopened, decades old, after her grandmother died.

Think of a recurring financial worry you carry, whether it's a bill, an insurance gap, or a purchase you keep postponing, and treat fixing it the way you'd treat fixing a bad back, as removing a source of constant low-grade pain rather than as a luxury. If you tend to scramble for basics at the last minute, buy them ahead of need this week instead, even if it feels indulgent. Find one thing you've been saving for a special occasion, good stationery, a nice bottle of something, and use it now, on an ordinary day, rather than waiting. And pick one category of spending you can give up entirely, not because you can't afford it, but for the specific relief of having decided, once, instead of negotiating with yourself every single time.

What You'll Achieve

The listener stops arguing over whether money can buy happiness in the abstract and instead starts noticing where money is currently a source of constant low-grade unhappiness in their own life, fixing that specifically, and spending deliberately on the few things that actually support their happiness rather than randomly or guiltily.

Spend in ways that actually support happiness

1

Sort spending by what it's actually for

Health, relationships, work efficiency, memories, or giving, rather than by category of object.

2

Buy needful things before you run out

If you're an underbuyer who waits until the last minute, stock the basics ahead of need instead of scrambling.

3

Spend out rather than save for later

Use the good stationery, wear the nice pen, don't let things sit saved indefinitely.

4

Give up one category deliberately

Choose a specific class of purchase to stop entirely, for the feeling of control it brings, not just the money saved.

Reflection Questions

  • What financial worry are you currently carrying that functions like an untreated injury, always in the background?
  • Are you an underbuyer who scrambles at the last minute, or an overbuyer who stockpiles more than you need?
  • What are you saving right now that you could actually use today?

Personalization Tips

  • Someone who keeps good towels in a cupboard for guests who never come could start using them now, instead of waiting for an occasion that may never arrive.
  • A person who feels vaguely guilty every time they buy takeout could instead decide, once, to give up ordering lunch delivery entirely, and feel the relief of a made decision rather than a daily negotiation.
The Happiness Project: Or Why I Spent a Year Trying to Sing in the Morning, Clean My Closets, Fight Right, Read Aristotle, and Generally Have More Fun
← Back to Book

The Happiness Project: Or Why I Spent a Year Trying to Sing in the Morning, Clean My Closets, Fight Right, Read Aristotle, and Generally Have More Fun

Gretchen Rubin • 2009
Insight 7 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.