Hunger is a trained signal you can retrain in a week

Medium - Requires some preparation Recommended

You feel a pull toward the pantry at 9 p.m., even after dinner. It’s not hunger from need, it’s a habit loop. A cue (sofa + shows) triggers a routine (snack) that delivers a reward (soothing). To change the loop, you don’t fight the cue, you swap the routine. Tonight, you park a mug of mint tea on the coffee table before you sit down. When the urge arrives, the mug is there, warm, easy.

The first few nights, your stomach growls and the show’s snack scene makes it worse. You breathe, sip, and set a 10-minute timer. Around minute six, the wave crests and fades. You note, almost surprised, how quickly it vanished. On night four, the urge is milder. On night seven, you forget the snack until the credits roll and your tea is half gone and lukewarm.

Hunger is profoundly Pavlovian. You trained your body to expect food at certain times and contexts, so your body preps for it. The salivary glands and even insulin can ramp up on expectation alone. The good news is that learned hunger unlearns fast when you stay consistent. A small replacement routine gives your brain something to do while the wave passes. That’s why walking, tea, or even tidying can work.

I might be wrong, but most people don’t need more willpower, they need structure. The 10-minute rule and a written log create feedback. You stop fearing the feeling because you’ve watched it rise and fall like a tide. After a week, cues lose their punch, and you’re free to eat when you planned, not when a showrunner decided to insert a pizza ad.

This lines up with classical conditioning and habit-loop research. Conditioned responses weaken with extinction, and replacement routines maintain reward without reinforcing the old behavior. In fasting, this makes the difference between white-knuckling and calm compliance.

List the three moments you most often eat on autopilot, then pre-load a five-minute alternative for each—cinnamon tea at 9 p.m., a hallway lap at 10 a.m., a podcast during your commute. When the urge hits, start your replacement and set a 10-minute timer to surf the wave. Rate the intensity and note when it fades, so you build proof that cravings pass quickly. If the feeling lingers after your timer, use a planned option like sparkling water or broth and carry on with your schedule. Do this for one week and watch those cues lose their grip.

What You'll Achieve

Internally, reduce anxiety about cravings and build trust that hunger waves pass. Externally, cut unplanned snacking by replacing cue-driven eating with brief, satisfying rituals.

Break cue-driven eating loops

1

Name your top three eating cues

Examples include the 10 a.m. meeting, the drive home, or Netflix at 9 p.m. Write them down to make them visible.

2

Install a replacement ritual

Pair each cue with a new 5-minute behavior: cinnamon tea, a short walk, or tidying your desk. The goal is to ride the hunger wave.

3

Use the 10-minute rule

When a craving hits, set a timer and do your replacement. If hunger persists after 10 minutes, choose a planned option like a sparkling water or a small broth.

4

Log hunger intensity and duration

Rate cravings 1–10 and note how long until they pass. Most peak and drop within 15–20 minutes, which builds confidence.

Reflection Questions

  • Which cue is the easiest to replace this week, and what’s your new ritual?
  • What did your last craving feel like at minute 1, 5, and 10?
  • How will you reward yourself for sticking to the replacement for seven days?

Personalization Tips

  • Parenting: Swap the post-bedtime snack with a couch stretch routine and mint tea while you debrief the day.
  • Office: Replace vending-machine runs with a quick lap around the building and a cold seltzer.
  • Gaming/creative: During late sessions, set a 90-minute focus block, then brew cinnamon tea as your break ritual.
The Complete Guide to Fasting: Heal Your Body Through Intermittent, Alternate-Day, and Extended Fasting
← Back to Book

The Complete Guide to Fasting: Heal Your Body Through Intermittent, Alternate-Day, and Extended Fasting

Jason Fung,Jimmy Moore 2016
Insight 3 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.