Cut Every Scene That Doesn’t Breathe Your Core Idea
The most memorable stories feel effortless, yet they are masterpieces of economy. Every scene, every line of dialogue, should serve one master: your core idea. When a subplot wanders off or a character cameo delights but distracts, your narrative pulse falters.
Imagine your story as a muscle: it thrives on resistance that builds strength and wastes away in idle hours. By tagging every scene with your central conflict—you might call it “a single rat’s dream to cook” or “a widower’s struggle to let go”—you instantly reveal clutter. Scenes that don’t echo or escalate that conflict become dead weight.
This approach draws from cognitive load theory: our brains focus best when we limit extraneous information. When you prune your narrative, you free your audience to engage fully with the drama. No background chatter, just the beating heart of your story.
Next time you draft, build in an economy check: after each draft, revisit every scene with the question, “How does this advance my core idea?” If the answer isn’t immediate and crisp, cut or reshape until it is. That disciplined ruthlessness yields lean, powerful storytelling.
First, distill your narrative into a single sentence that captures your central conflict. Then, scan your outline or draft, annotating each scene with that core idea. Flag scenes that can’t make the connection. Finally, remove or reshape those flagged moments until you’re left with a tight chain of scenes that all pulse with the same dramatic heart. This is how you build a story free of clutter and full of impact.
What You'll Achieve
You’ll gain a mindset of disciplined clarity, producing drafts free of distraction and externally achieving faster revising cycles with stronger narrative cohesion.
Audit your story for purity
Highlight your story seed
In one sentence, capture your central emotional conflict or theme—this is your core idea.
Tag each scene
Go through your outline or draft and write the core idea next to every scene. If any scene can’t plausibly link, flag it.
Prune ruthlessly
Delete or rework flagged scenes. Ask: does this moment advance, echo, or complicate the central idea? If not, eliminate.
Test economy again
After pruning, glance over your draft. Every remaining scene should feel essential and coherent with your core conflict.
Reflection Questions
- Can you state your story’s core idea in one clear sentence?
- Which scenes feel like detours rather than direct paths to that idea?
- What gets lost when you remove these digressions?
- How does your story tighten when only essential scenes remain?
Personalization Tips
- In a thesis, ensure every paragraph ties back to your research question to avoid academic fluff.
- In a marketing deck, remove slides that don’t directly support your sales argument.
- In a training manual, cut modules that don’t reinforce the main learning objective.
Pixar Storytelling: Rules for Effective Storytelling Based on Pixar’s Greatest Films
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.