Make Facts, Not Feelings, Decide What Stays in Your Home

Medium - Requires some preparation Recommended

I sat cross-legged in my daughter’s playroom, surrounded by stacked bins of costume jewelry and half-used craft kits. My heart raced—each piece carried memories. But behind my emotional haze, I felt stuck. I realized I was practicing “stuff-shifting,” moving items from one bin to another, hoping future me would decide.

Pausing, I placed a plastic tiara on my knee and breathed. “Where would I look for this?” I asked myself. No answer. Then, “Would I even remember I own it?” My mind drew a blank. I felt a gentle click—fact over feeling. I dropped the tiara into a donate bag. The room felt lighter; my posture softened.

Mindfulness research shows that nonjudgmental awareness of our instinctive patterns creates space for choice. By replacing emotions with two simple, fact-based questions, I avoided the spiral of guilt and indecision that kept my playroom imprisoned.

That afternoon, I cleared three bins without tears. Each release felt honest and freeing. The next time I walked through that room, I noticed the silence—no more magic wands underfoot. I had become an observer, not a slave to sentiment.

Notice when you start shifting items instead of deciding. Pause and hold one item, then ask yourself where you’d look for it first and whether you’d recall owning it. If you can’t answer both, place it in your donate box. This simple pause teaches your brain facts over feelings. Try it with one item now.

What You'll Achieve

You’ll gain clarity, reduce emotional paralysis, and consistently make fact-based decisions that keep your spaces under control.

Decide on Items by Facts, Not Feelings

1

Spot stuff-shifting

Notice when you move items from one spot to another instead of removing them—you’re avoiding a real decision.

2

Ask location first

Hold an item and ask, “Where would I look for this?” If you can’t name a spot, it’s not earning a home.

3

Check memory recall

If you’d never think to look for it, ask, “Would I even recall I own this?” If not, let it go without emotional debate.

Reflection Questions

  • What belongings cause you the most emotional tug?
  • How do fact-based questions change your decision-making?
  • Where might you apply this approach beyond physical clutter?

Personalization Tips

  • A photographer sorts old lenses by return-spot: gear bag or donate box.
  • A driver asks where he’d search for that extra charger if lost—if nowhere, he tosses it.
  • A writer tests if she could recall an unused notebook before buying a new one—if not, she donates the old.
Organizing for the Rest of Us: 100 Realistic Strategies to Keep Any House Under Control
← Back to Book

Organizing for the Rest of Us: 100 Realistic Strategies to Keep Any House Under Control

Dana K. White 2022
Insight 8 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.