Listen First by Killing the Need to Be Right

Medium - Requires some preparation Recommended

You’re halfway through arguing with a colleague about a project schedule when you suddenly realize the color has drained from your cheeks and your jaw is clenched. Internally you’re thinking, “She has no clue what she’s asking for!” But rather than fire back, you pause and label your mood as “defensive.” You take a breath and force yourself to break the loop of being right.

“Can you walk me through your timeline?” you ask instead. Your colleague hesitates, taken aback, but then launches into her reasoning. You listen—no interruptions—focusing on understanding rather than rebuttal. When she finishes, you paraphrase her core point and admit, “I hadn’t considered that our resource availability could shift so quickly.” The conversation flows from there, and together you draft a plan that respects both viewpoints.

This pivot from “I must be right” to “I want to learn” transforms conflict into collaboration. Social psychologists call this intellectual humility—an openness that builds trust and invites richer dialogue. By killing the need to be right, you unlock every person’s creative potential and experience firsthand why curiosity is the ultimate performance booster.

The next time you feel your defenses spike, pause and silently label your emotional state—“I’m defensive.” Then ask your counterpart to explain their view: “Help me understand your timeline concern.” Listen fully, without plotting your reply. Finally, reflect back one thing you heard and ask a follow-up question. You’ll find conversation shifts from contention to collaboration in minutes.

What You'll Achieve

You’ll gain the ability to transform tense interactions into productive dialogue, heightening team cohesion. Externally, others will respond more openly, accelerating problem-solving.

Swap Defensiveness for Curiosity

1

Notice Your Defensiveness Tone

During your next disagreement, silently label your tone: “defensive,” “argumentative,” or “impatient.” That simple awareness disrupts your mental autopilot.

2

Ask a Curious Question

Instead of countering a point, ask “Help me understand how you see this.” Let the other person finish before you speak; listen without interrupting.

3

Acknowledge What You Haven’t Heard

Paraphrase a key phrase they said, then say, “That piece surprises me—tell me more.” This shifts you from defending yourself to genuinely seeking new insights.

Reflection Questions

  • What moments do you most often feel the need to defend yourself?
  • Who could you practice curiosity with this week?
  • How might your day change if you spent five minutes listening first?
  • What one question can you ask next time you disagree?
  • How will you remind yourself to label defensiveness in the heat of the moment?

Personalization Tips

  • In a board meeting, resist jumping in on every objection; watch your tone, then ask the speaker to elaborate on their concern.
  • When coaching your child on chores, note your urge to scold, label it, then ask, “What’s hard for you about this task?”
  • If a colleague clips you in email, pause, note your rising heat, and reply, “I’d like to hear more about your perspective here.”
Leading Lightly: Lower Your Stress, Think with Clarity, and Lead with Ease
← Back to Book

Leading Lightly: Lower Your Stress, Think with Clarity, and Lead with Ease

Jody Michael 2022
Insight 5 of 7

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.