That eye-roll about someone else's expensive car reveals more about you

Easy - Can start today

It's easy to spot someone else's flaws from a comfortable distance: her photos look staged, his smile is obviously fake, that car is just for show. What's harder to spot is what those judgments are actually doing while they leave your mouth, which is describing you far more accurately than they're describing the person you're aiming them at.

Consider three ordinary complaints. "Why does that girl's account have more followers than mine, her photos aren't even that good," usually means you wish your own following were bigger and would rather resent hers than examine that wish directly. "Look at him, always smiling and nice to everyone, it must be fake," usually means some part of you is jealous of how easily he connects with people, and finds it safer to call him a fraud than to ask why your own life doesn't feel that light. "He thinks he's important because of his car and his house, so superficial," usually means the car and the house are exactly the kind of thing you wish you had, and criticizing him is cheaper than admitting that.

It's genuinely difficult to find someone secure in themselves who also judges other people harshly. The two states rarely coexist, because judgment tends to be a defense mechanism, a way of managing an insecurity by aiming it outward instead of sitting with it. This doesn't mean every critical thought is secretly self-loathing in disguise, but it does mean that a harsh, instant verdict about a stranger is worth a second look before you trust it as an honest read on them.

None of this means judgment can be switched off entirely, and pretending otherwise isn't realistic. What can change is the habit of stopping there. The useful alternative is curiosity: instead of concluding that someone is fake, or arrogant, or stupid, ask a different, quieter question. Is there something going on with this person that I can't see? That question doesn't demand an answer on the spot. It simply keeps the case open a little longer, long enough to notice that the sharp comment you were about to make, or send, says more about what you're carrying than about the person on the other end of it, and once said or sent, it can't be taken back.

The next time you catch yourself mocking or dismissing someone, whether out loud or just in your own head, pause on the thought instead of letting it finish itself. Ask honestly whether what's bothering you about them is actually a want of your own in disguise, more followers, more ease with people, more money. Then swap the verdict for a question: is there something going on with this person that I can't see? And before you send the sharp text or make the cutting remark, give yourself a moment to consider how it will land, since it's the one thing, once out, you won't get to take back.

What You'll Achieve

The listener learns to recognize harsh judgments of others as information about their own insecurities rather than accurate readings of the other person, and builds the habit of replacing a snap verdict with curiosity, which reduces unnecessary conflict and increases self-understanding.

Turn judgment into curiosity instead

1

*Catch yourself mid-judgment*

The moment you notice yourself dismissing or mocking someone, pause on the thought instead of letting it run its course silently.

2

*Ask what the judgment says about your own insecurity*

If you're annoyed by someone's confidence, their success, or their possessions, ask honestly whether you're actually reacting to something you wish you had yourself.

3

*Replace the verdict with a question*

Instead of concluding someone is fake, arrogant, or stupid, ask yourself, 'is there something going on with this person that I can't see?' This single question reopens a case you'd already closed.

4

*Pause before sending anything sharp*

Before you send a critical text, comment, or remark, wait long enough to consider how it will land on the other end, since words you can't take back can leave a mark you didn't intend.

Reflection Questions

  • What's the last harsh judgment you made about someone, and what might it reveal about something you want for yourself?
  • Can you think of someone secure in themselves who also judges others constantly? What does that tell you?
  • When you feel the urge to mock or dismiss someone, what happens if you pause and ask what's really going on with them instead?
  • Have you ever sent or said something critical you couldn't take back, and what would you have done differently with a little more pause?

Personalization Tips

  • Scrolling social media, someone catches themselves thinking a stranger's vacation photos are 'try-hard' and realizes it's their own envy talking, not an honest read on the stranger.
  • A colleague dismisses a peer's promotion as 'just office politics' and, pressed to explain why, admits it's really about their own disappointment at being passed over.
How to Read People Like a Book: Understand People Beyond Words: A Complete Guide to Accurately Reading Intentions, Body Language, Thoughts and Emotions
← Back to Book

How to Read People Like a Book: Understand People Beyond Words: A Complete Guide to Accurately Reading Intentions, Body Language, Thoughts and Emotions

Ian Tuhovsky • 2022
Insight 8 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.