Hire for honesty and multiply your impact

Hard - Requires significant effort Recommended

In 2003, Warren Buffett flew to Little Rock for a single two-hour meeting, then shook hands on a $23 billion acquisition—no reams of due diligence required. He trusted Sam Walton’s word and a well-built structure more than pages of contracts.

This same principle applies to every hire. When you build trust first—by vetting integrity, intelligence, and initiative—you gain a team member who requires minimal oversight. They own their work, raise their hand when problems arise, and fuel progress without micromanagement.

In one entrepreneurial firm, a single high-integrity controller replaced a series of short-term hires riddled with errors. The new hire’s consistent honesty and follow-through meant fewer audits, fewer surprises, and a culture of accountability that spread across projects.

The lesson: hire character before skill. In return, you’ll enjoy smoother team dynamics, faster decision-making, and a self-sustaining engine of trust that magnifies every ounce of effort.

Begin every interview by identifying three key integrity traits your team can’t live without. Pose questions that demand concrete examples—“Describe a time you admitted a mistake”—and listen for genuine self-awareness. Before you make an offer, call references and ask about one ethical challenge they faced. If any hesitation arises, trust your gut. Remember, one bulletproof hire transforms your entire operation.

What You'll Achieve

You’ll cultivate a high-trust culture that reduces oversight, accelerates execution, and multiplies team performance.

Vet character before skill in interviews

1

Define core integrity traits

Decide which values matter most—honesty, responsibility, respect. Write them down so every interviewer knows what to look for.

2

Craft behavioral questions

Ask candidates to share real examples, such as “Tell me about a time you owned up to a mistake.” Genuine stories reveal character far more than polished answers.

3

Verify with references

Call former managers and team members specifically about integrity. Ask whether the candidate ever faced an ethical dilemma and how they handled it.

4

Trust your instincts

If you still sense red flags—hesitation, vague language, or defensiveness—pause. A single hard-won hire is worth more than a dozen you’ll regret.

Reflection Questions

  • What values are nonnegotiable on your team?
  • How thoroughly do your current hires reflect those values?
  • What might you learn by probing one past mistake in an upcoming interview?

Personalization Tips

  • A startup founder hires a cofounder by first vetting trustworthiness before technical prowess.
  • A volunteer coordinator screens team leads by asking for concrete examples of keeping promises.
  • A parent chooses a babysitter after checking a neighbor’s recommendation and probing about past challenges.
Effortless: Make It Easier to Do What Matters Most
← Back to Book

Effortless: Make It Easier to Do What Matters Most

Greg McKeown 2021
Insight 7 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.