The insult that revealed the real difference between heaven and hell
A blunt, battle-hardened samurai once strode up to a Zen master sitting in meditation and demanded to be told, right then, the nature of heaven and hell. The master opened his eyes and looked him over with open contempt. Why, he asked, should he waste a single word on a shabby, disgusting slob like this. Get out of his sight.
The samurai's face went red. No one spoke to him that way. He drew his sword, raised it, and prepared to take the master's head off on the spot.
The master looked calmly up into his enraged face and said, that's hell.
The samurai froze. In an instant he saw exactly what had just happened to him: a few insulting words had produced enough fury to make him ready to kill a man in cold blood. His own mind had built the hell he was standing in, not the master's rudeness. He lowered the sword, and tears came to his eyes. He bowed.
And that, the master said gently, is heaven.
Joseph Nguyen uses this story to make a point about what to actually do once you recognize that thinking is producing your suffering: not fight it, but let it settle. He compares a thinking mind to a bowl of cloudy, dirty water. Most people, handed that bowl, assume they need to filter it or boil it clean. But if you simply set the bowl down and leave it alone, the dirt sinks to the bottom on its own, and the water clears itself, because clarity is water's natural state when undisturbed.
He argues our minds work the same way. Trying to argue yourself out of an emotion, force positivity, or aggressively problem-solve your way to calm tends to stir the very thinking that's causing the distress, the way struggling in quicksand only pulls you under faster. The way out, in both cases, is closer to stopping the fight and trusting that your body, or your mind, will settle if you let it. The samurai didn't need a lecture on Buddhist philosophy to reach heaven. He needed one clear, unfiltered second in which he saw the water was murky, and it began, immediately, to clear.
When you feel a strong reaction rising, start simply by noticing that a great deal of thinking is happening right now, before you try to fix or explain anything. Resist the pull to immediately argue yourself out of the feeling or force a solution, since pushing against thinking, like boiling murky water, usually stirs it up further rather than clearing it. Instead, give yourself a few unhurried minutes to just sit with what's there, trusting that it will settle the way dirt sinks to the bottom of still water. When you check back in, notice whatever shift has happened without judging how fast or slow it was, and repeat the same quiet waiting if the feeling hasn't fully cleared yet.
What You'll Achieve
You develop a way to handle strong emotion that doesn't involve fighting it, so arguments and stressful moments burn out faster instead of escalating through your own resistance. Others may notice you de-escalate rather than double down when provoked.
Steps to let thinking settle on its own
Notice you're thinking before trying to fix anything
When you feel stress rising, the first move is simply to recognize that a lot of thinking is happening right now, without yet trying to change or argue with any of it.
Stop trying to filter or force it away
Resist the urge to immediately problem-solve, distract, or argue yourself out of the feeling. Effort applied at this stage tends to stir things up further, the way boiling murky water doesn't clear it.
Give it space and let it sit
Set a few minutes aside to simply be with the feeling without acting on it, the way dirt in still water settles to the bottom on its own given time.
Check back in without judging the pace
After some time has passed, notice whether the intensity has dropped. If it hasn't fully cleared, that's fine; repeat the process without treating the delay as a failure.
Reflection Questions
- What is your usual first move when you feel a strong negative emotion, and does it tend to calm things down or stir them up further?
- Can you recall a time a feeling cleared simply because you waited, without doing anything to fix it?
- Where in your life are you currently fighting a feeling the way someone might fight quicksand?
Personalization Tips
- Someone furious after a heated meeting can feel the anger sharply, and if they resist firing back an email for an hour, the urge often fades on its own.
- A person spiraling before a big decision at midnight often finds that the same decision looks calmer and clearer after simply sleeping on it.
- Parents mid-argument who agree to pause for ten minutes rather than push the conversation through anger frequently find the original complaint has softened by the time they return to it.
Don't Believe Everything You Think: Why Your Thinking Is The Beginning & End Of Suffering (Beyond Suffering Book 1)
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.