See your choice in the wider world to avoid wishful thinking
Imagine you’re deciding between two neighborhoods. The inside view urges you to trust your gut: you love the tree-lined streets of Brooklyn Heights, so naturally you lean that way. But the outside view demands data: neighborhood crime rates, school performance, average commute times. If you stopped there, you’d miss the texture: hired movers’ warnings about clogged garages in winter, the sweet hum of Sunday farmers’ markets. So you merge both: you chart each zip-code’s 10-year home-value trends next to three vivid stories you gathered from residents. That combined view—zooming out for broad base rates and zooming in for sensory-rich close-ups—is what researchers call de-biasing your decision. It prevents your mental spotlight from ignoring half the landscape, giving you both the forest and the best trailheads within it. Suddenly you’re not just choosing by intuition or by raw data alone, but by thoughtfully combining them.
First, pull simple data to anchor your outlook—regional stats, average turnover rates, or market research—so you can treat rosy guesses with healthy skepticism. Then talk to someone who’s lived your decision roughly—ask them how the nicest sunset in their new home felt, or how a harsh winter packed their driveway with ice. Finally, weave the two: list one number-backed rule and one story-inspired insight. Test them in a low-stakes way—take a gravel-road drive, step on the brake at landmarks, and see how it feels. Bring both map and compass. Try it this week.
What You'll Achieve
You’ll balance intuition with evidence, making choices that neither gullible hopes nor stale stats alone could produce. Internally, you’ll feel grounded; externally, you’ll spot pitfalls and opportunities with equal clarity.
Combine zoomed-out and zoomed-in views
Consult the base rates
Research how often similar decisions succeed or fail in your context—for instance, the percentage of startups that survive five years. This outside perspective keeps you honest.
Gather real stories
Interview two people who have walked your path—one who triumphed and one who stumbled. Ask them to share three sensory details of their experience.
Map your parallels
Draw two columns: in one, key factors from the base rates (e.g., ‘20% survive’); in the other, vivid insights from your interviews (‘I was up all night debugging’).
Bridge the gap
Draft a quick action plan that uses statistics to set guardrails (e.g., “Ensure 80% of teams have usability testing”), then add a story-inspired habit (“Review code at midnight with a buddy to catch hidden bugs”).
Reflection Questions
- What base rate are you ignoring in your choices?
- Who can offer a close-up story of that decision path?
- How will you combine data and narrative next time?
Personalization Tips
- Before switching careers, check labor-market stats for job growth while also shadowing two people on the job for a day.
- When weighing a moving decision, review neighborhood crime and commute data, then spend an evening strolling the streets.
- If you’re investing, look at five-year returns for similar startups, then talk to one founder who cashed out and one who went under.
Decisive: How to Make Better Choices in Life and Work
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.