See What You’ve Been Blind To by Actively Seeking Disagreements

Medium - Requires some preparation Recommended

You’ve spent days refining that big pitch, rehearsed every word, yet when you present it to a group of colleagues, not one voice will rise. The silence is deafening. You tune into every breath, every flicker of a cursor, waiting for someone to speak.

Then Greg—the one who rarely talks—raises a single point: “What if your target audience isn’t this group? What if it’s a niche you can’t see?” Your heart pounds, but you also feel a surge of clarity that the missing link might be right there in Greg’s question.

Moments like that can feel like being zapped by a cold breeze—sharp, unexpected, but vital. The mind-quieting silence gives way to new perspective. Already, you envision changes that could make your plan resonate with the people who matter most.

This kind of mindful challenge—inviting someone to understand and disrupt your assumptions—breaks you free from your own models. By practising openness to disagreement, you notice the hidden gaps in your thinking and replace stale certainty with fresh insight.

Neuroscience shows that confronting alternative views engages neural circuitry for deeper learning and sparks curiosity. When you lean in, you don’t just patch holes—you expand your vision.

Tonight, ask a trusted colleague to play devil’s advocate and question your next plan—promise them full comment freedom. Invite one new person to challenge a key assumption, then listen deeply for the unexpected insight. Afterward, map out which surprise note you’ll tackle first. This simple ritual of friendly pushback will sharpen your thinking and reveal blind spots no lab meeting ever could—try it this afternoon.

What You'll Achieve

You’ll cultivate a culture of trust and healthy debate that surfaces hidden issues, improving decision quality and reducing blind-spot errors by 40%.

Invite Pleasant Pushback

1

Share your draft outline.

Present your next project overview to colleagues, asking them specifically for the toughest critique—no sugar-coating.

2

Assign a devil’s advocate.

At each meeting, rotate this role: one person’s job is to challenge assumptions, spot gaps, and counter your logic.

3

Rotate the champion role.

Next time, have someone else champion the idea, raising new angles and minimizing groupthink.

4

Reflect on feedback.

After each session, jot down what surprised you most, what you resisted, and what insights you’ll act on first.

Reflection Questions

  • When was the last time someone disagreed with you in private?
  • How did you respond—and how did it change your perspective?
  • Who could you invite into a discussion to test your next big idea?

Personalization Tips

  • In a family budget: ask your spouse to critique your spending plan.
  • In a workout group: challenge your coach’s routine by suggesting an alternative set.
  • In a book club: debate the author’s main premise as a group exercise.
Creativity, Inc.: Overcoming the Unseen Forces That Stand in the Way of True Inspiration
← Back to Book

Creativity, Inc.: Overcoming the Unseen Forces That Stand in the Way of True Inspiration

Ed Catmull, Amy Wallace 2014
Insight 4 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.