Speed‑read personalities with the Big Five and adapt your approach
Personality isn’t a box, it’s a map. The Big Five traits—Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness, and Neuroticism—describe how people tend to approach change, structure, people, cooperation, and threat. About half of this is wired, the rest shaped by life. When you know your map and sketch someone else’s, you stop taking differences personally and start working with them.
Suppose you’re high in conscientiousness and your coworker is low. You love plans and lists. They love flexibility and broad strokes. If you keep sending long checklists, they’ll avoid them. If they keep “winging it,” you’ll worry. Decide to compromise: agree on one clear outcome and two milestones, then give them room to execute their way while you track dates. Or optimize: if you’re inviting them to brainstorm, skip the spreadsheet and bring a whiteboard.
Another pairing: high openness with low openness. One wants novelty, the other prefers the known. For high‑open friends, suggest trying a new taco place but keep a favorite dish on the table. For low‑open clients, start with what won’t change, then introduce one small improvement.
This isn’t stereotyping. It’s empathy with a plan. You’ll still surprise each other. You’ll still adapt. But tailoring your approach by trait prevents friction that feels personal but is just preference.
Practically, ask a few questions, watch for clues, then choose: optimize or compromise. Pitches and plans land better when they match how a person processes the world, from details to safety to social energy.
Map your own OCEAN and note two traits that most affect your work with others. For your next important conversation, infer the other person’s likely traits from clues or ask a couple of light questions, then decide whether you’ll optimize to their style or propose a compromise, and tailor your message—vision or details, group or one‑on‑one, reassurance or challenge. This small adjustment pays off fast. Test it this week.
What You'll Achieve
Internally, replace frustration with understanding and choice. Externally, reduce miscommunications, increase buy‑in, and accelerate agreements by matching how you communicate to how others think.
Sketch their OCEAN, then flex
Self‑map your OCEAN
Rate yourself high/low/middle on Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness, Neuroticism. Notice where you shine and where you strain.
Ask or infer theirs
Use direct questions or behavioral clues: planners’ calendars scream high conscientiousness, variety lovers hint at high openness, one‑on‑ones soothe introverts.
Choose optimize or compromise
If traits clash, either adapt your approach (optimize) or find a middle path (compromise). Decide before the meeting how you’ll adjust.
Tailor pitches by trait
High openness wants new possibilities, high conscientiousness wants details, introverts prefer prep, high agreeableness needs safety, high neuroticism needs safeguards.
Reflection Questions
- Which of my traits clash most often with others?
- What clues reliably reveal each Big Five trait in my context?
- Where will optimize vs. compromise make the biggest difference this month?
- How can I document what works with each person?
Personalization Tips
- Sales call: With a high‑conscientious buyer, send a one‑page brief with timelines and risks before the meeting; with a high‑open founder, lead with vision and options.
- Studying: If your lab partner is introverted, share notes ahead and meet in a quiet space for focused work.
Captivate: The Science of Succeeding with People
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.