Create conversational sparks that people replay and remember
You know the script by heart. “What do you do?” “How’s it going?” “Been busy?” It fills air, then dies. You finish the chat and can’t remember their name by the time your coffee turns cold. The fix isn’t more charm, it’s better questions and attention to what the brain loves: novelty, specificity, and small rewards.
Start with a tiny upgrade. Instead of “How are you?” try “What was the highlight of your day?” Watch for the moment their voice picks up or their shoulders rise. That’s a hot button. Linger. Ask, “How did that happen?” or “What surprised you about it?” When you do, you give them a little dopamine bump, the same inner “yes” we feel when we get a small win. People remember who made them feel that.
You can also use the oddball effect on purpose. Slightly unusual prompts wake people up. A friend once asked me, “What’s a tiny experiment you’re running on yourself this month?” We ended up trading the funniest stories about screen‑time hacks and cold showers. Two weeks later, we were swapping progress updates like teammates. I might be wrong, but I don’t think we’d have bonded over “So, what’s new?”
Names matter, too. Repeat the name back, picture it spelled out, and tie it to something vivid. “Nice to meet you, Eliza… with a Z.” Or link “Syder” to a mug of cider in your head. Later, when you say their name without hesitation, it’s another small reward they feel as care.
Under the hood, novelty cues the brain’s reward pathways, and specific follow‑ups deepen encoding in memory. Hot‑button hunting keeps you in the zones where people feel enthusiastic, which creates more enjoyable, sticky conversations and reduces the urge to escape back to your phone.
Ditch one stale opener and use a fresh one that invites a story, then watch for the first sign of lift in their voice or posture and stay with it using two follow‑ups. Add one specific, slightly odd prompt to spark novelty, and anchor their name by repeating it and linking it to a vivid image. You’ll feel the conversation click into place. Try this with the next person you greet today.
What You'll Achieve
Internally, feel at ease steering chats away from small talk. Externally, spark engaging, memorable conversations that lead to real follow‑ups and stronger relationships.
Swap scripts for novelty and hot buttons
Retire dead‑end starters
Scrap “How are you?” and “What do you do?” Replace with prompts that surface stories, like “What was the highlight of your day?” or “Working on anything you’re excited about?”
Listen for hot buttons
When someone lights up, leans in, or says “tell me more,” you’ve hit a hot button. Stay there with follow‑ups rather than hopping topics.
Use specific, odd prompts
Novelty perks up attention systems. Ask, “Tried any tiny experiments this week?” or “What’s a weird skill you recently learned?”
Play the Name Game
Anchor names by repeating them, spelling them in your head, and linking each to a person or object (Matt with poker table, Syder with cider).
Reflection Questions
- Which opener can I retire starting today?
- What are two novelty prompts I enjoy asking?
- How will I notice when someone ‘lights up’ so I can stay there?
- What name‑anchoring trick works best for me?
Personalization Tips
- Remote one‑on‑one: Open with “What’s one bright spot from this week?” then follow their energy instead of your agenda for five minutes.
- Health club: Ask the front‑desk regular, “What’s your favorite ‘I didn’t expect to like this’ exercise?”
Captivate: The Science of Succeeding with People
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.