Use FBI-born elicitation to make anyone open up

Hard - Requires significant effort Recommended

Elicitation techniques trace back to FBI interrogation methods designed to make suspects talk without direct demands. Corporate spies picked them up next, realizing that a flattering remark or a feigned confusion invites people to speak more freely. You don’t need a hidden badge to use these tools for good.

In one example, a team lead complimented a junior analyst on the “impressive depth of your charts,” instantly prompting the analyst to detail their data-gathering process. In another, a marketing director confessed, “I don’t get why our campaign underperformed—maybe the keyword choice was off?” giving colleagues a chance to explain insights they otherwise withheld.

By alternating recognition, mild complaint, feigned naiveté, and minor error, you wire conversations toward expansion. These prompts exploit fundamental drives: people want praise, crave validation for their complaints, yearn to teach what they know, and can’t resist correcting mistakes. Ethically applied, elicitation transforms one-word answers into meaningful dialogue.

Understanding the psychology behind these moves invites intentionality. You shift from passively waiting for others to share, to gently guiding them into revealing thoughts and feelings. The result is richer, more productive interactions that benefit both sides.

One begins by offering genuine praise for a specific action, then sprinkling in a relatable complaint to invite solidarity. Next, feign a partial understanding to trigger their inner teacher, and finally make a harmless mistake they need to correct. This sequence, repeated thoughtfully, moves any conversation from surface to substance—try it tomorrow at lunch.

What You'll Achieve

You will learn to trigger natural conversational reflexes—seeking validation, unity, and clarity—leading to more open, detailed, and trustworthy exchanges in just minutes.

Apply four subtle prompts with care

1

Offer genuine recognition

Start with a specific compliment—“I admire how thorough your report was”—to play into the other person’s desire to explain their effort.

2

Share a light complaint

Voice a mild gripe like “I can’t stand this slow Wi-Fi” to invite commiseration or defense, sparking an emotional response.

3

Feign knowledgeable gaps

Say “I almost understand this concept, but one part confuses me” so they’ll step in to teach and clarify.

4

Introduce a minor error

Make a harmless incorrect statement—“I think our meeting is at 3:00, not 2:00?”—prompting them to correct you and elaborate.

Reflection Questions

  • Which elicitation prompt feels most natural to you?
  • How will you ensure your intent stays positive?
  • When will you apply one of these techniques this week?

Personalization Tips

  • With a teammate: “Your slide deck was so clear—how did you decide on that layout?”
  • At dinner: “I hate how slow these tacos fill me up—do you ever wish you could eat just salads?”
  • During workshops: “I thought I knew the theory, but I’m still unclear on this step. Can you help?”
Better Small Talk: Talk to Anyone, Avoid Awkwardness, Generate Deep Conversations, and Make Real Friends (How to be More Likable and Charismatic Book 6)
← Back to Book

Better Small Talk: Talk to Anyone, Avoid Awkwardness, Generate Deep Conversations, and Make Real Friends (How to be More Likable and Charismatic Book 6)

Patrick King 2020
Insight 5 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.