Why a law built to punish the rich ended up taxing everyone else

Hard - Requires significant effort Recommended

Here's a question worth sitting with for a second: if income tax was originally created specifically to make the rich pay their share, how did the middle class end up carrying so much of the load?

Robert Kiyosaki traces the answer back through the history his rich dad taught him. Income tax became permanent in Britain in 1874 and in the United States in 1913, and in both countries it took about fifty years to convince the public to accept it at all. The way it was sold, in both places, was the same: it would only ever apply to the wealthy. People voted for it believing they were protected from it forever.

The trouble, as Kiyosaki tells it, is that once a government has a taste of steady tax revenue, its appetite grows, and a government's success is measured differently than a business's. A business is rewarded for spending less than it takes in. A government agency that fails to spend its whole budget risks losing it next year, so there's no institutional reward for restraint. As spending grew, the tax net had to widen, sliding further down the income scale until it reached the very people who had voted it in, believing it would never touch them.

Meanwhile, the wealthy did something the general public mostly didn't understand: they moved their money into corporations, a legal structure that dates back to the trading ships of centuries ago, when investors used it to limit their losses to whatever they'd put into a single voyage. A corporation isn't a building or a factory. It's a file of legal paperwork registered with a government office, and inside that file money behaves by different rules. A corporation can spend on many expenses before it's taxed, while an individual employee is taxed first and lives on whatever's left. Kiyosaki's rich dad called this the biggest secret of the wealthy, not a loophole exactly, since it's entirely legal, but a structural advantage that most people never learn exists because school never teaches it.

Kiyosaki isn't arguing that the wealthy are cheating anyone. His point is narrower and, he thinks, more useful: the same laws are technically available to more people than use them, and not knowing they exist is itself what keeps the tax burden concentrated on wages rather than on the structures wealthier people quietly use instead.

Start by simply finding out what a legal entity like a small corporation or an LLC actually is in your situation, not to do anything drastic, but to understand the option exists before assuming it doesn't apply to you. If you have any income-producing activity at all, even something small on the side, ask an accountant or a knowledgeable friend what expenses could legally be paid before tax rather than after, and compare that to how your regular paycheck is taxed. Read a little about how the tax code treats different kinds of income differently, because the rules reward those who understand them and quietly cost those who don't. Treat this as ongoing education, not a one-time fix, since the details change and staying informed is itself the advantage.

What You'll Achieve

The listener understands why tax law shifted onto wages over time and stops assuming that legal structures like corporations are only for the already wealthy, becoming curious enough to learn the basics that apply to their own situation.

Steps to learn the rules the wealthy use

1

Learn what a legal entity actually is

Find out in plain terms what forming a small business structure involves before assuming it has nothing to do with you.

2

Ask how pre-tax spending works

If you have any side income at all, ask an accountant what expenses could legally be paid before tax rather than after.

3

Compare how your income types are taxed

Notice how your wages are taxed compared with any other income you might have, and ask why the difference exists.

4

Keep studying the rules

Treat tax and legal knowledge as an ongoing subject, since the advantage comes from understanding it, not from a single trick.

Reflection Questions

  • What do you actually know about how a corporation is taxed compared to how your wages are taxed?
  • Have you ever assumed a legal or financial structure wasn't for people like you without checking?
  • If a rule already exists and is legal, what stops more people from learning and using it?

Personalization Tips

  • A freelance graphic designer discovers that operating through a simple business structure lets her pay for software and a home office before tax, unlike a salaried friend who pays every bill with after-tax money.
  • A side-hustling baker looks into whether her small catering income could be organized differently once it grows, instead of assuming taxes just are what they are.
Rich Dad, Poor Dad
← Back to Book

Rich Dad, Poor Dad

Robert T. Kiyosaki
Insight 4 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.