The Truth About ‘Necessary’ Expenses and Why Your Budget Isn’t Honest
Most people believe their budgets are tight because their needs are overwhelming, but need and want blur easily. There’s always just one more thing—a coffee to get through class, a new app that promises productivity, a fancier dinner to celebrate a tiny win. Yet, behavioral economics shows that spending always expands to the income available, unless you consciously resist.
In hundreds of households, detailed spending diaries reveal a universal pattern: people’s ‘necessary’ expenses tend to scale almost exactly with their pay, regardless of actual cost of living. Overlooked subscriptions, small luxuries, and default choices accumulate invisibly. The result is a monthly squeeze that feels inevitable.
Financial coaches often uncover shocking truths: two friends earning unequal salaries are both just as broke at the end of the month because their ‘needs’ have quietly adapted to fit their paychecks. The lesson? Desire is infinite, but money isn’t. Getting honest about your real basics—food, shelter, health, a bare handful of joys—is uncomfortable. But it’s the only way to spot and fix the leaks.
The essential behavioral principle is that every budget reflects not just math, but mindset. Only when you challenge your own assumptions and make the unconscious visible do you gain the power to direct your wealth rather than watch it drift away.
To get in control, start by writing down every regular expense you have—don’t overlook the tiny ones. Take a little time to label which are absolute essentials. Then, push yourself to identify at least one or two regular spending habits you can dial back. Set yourself a daily cap on all the fun or spontaneous buys, and keep a close eye on going over—by seeing it, you’ll start to manage it. The work isn’t easy at first, but you’ll be surprised how quick small cuts add up and how much lighter you start to feel.
What You'll Achieve
Achieve insight into your spending choices, reduce unnecessary expenses, and gain real control, leading to more consistent savings and a sense of intentional living.
Uncover and Cut Your Invisible Spending Drains
List your monthly spending by category.
Write down every recurring expense—food, rent, subscriptions, clothes, snacks. Don’t skip anything, no matter how small or ‘obvious.’
Mark what’s truly necessary.
Ask: does this keep me healthy, secure, employed, or connected to my core goals? Mark only these as ‘musts.’
Identify what you can cut or reduce.
Challenge your assumptions about comfort. Ask yourself if a smaller phone plan, fewer takeouts, or less expensive brands would really harm your happiness.
Create a daily spending cap for non-essentials.
Set a limit for ‘fun’ or impulse buys, and track it daily so your spending doesn’t creep back to fill your income.
Reflection Questions
- Which expense did you think was a ‘need’ but now see you might cut?
- What patterns did you find in your spending that surprised you?
- How would it feel to have money left over every month for your future?
- What triggers your impulse to spend beyond your budget?
Personalization Tips
- You notice your music streaming, gaming, and meal deliveries together cost more than your groceries, so you pick one to pause this month.
- A family drafts two lists: 'needs' (utilities, rent, basic groceries) and 'wants' (gourmet coffee, new shoes) and agrees to defer half the 'wants' for three months.
- A student switches from daily $5 snacks to bringing fruit from home and uses the $20 saved weekly to pay down a credit card.
The Richest Man in Babylon
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.