Unmasking the Link Between Shame, Disengagement, and Organizational Failure
At a well-known corporation, things look good on paper: steady profits, a sharp team, and a clear mission. Yet, behind closed doors, staff turnover is high, innovation is slow, and anxiety pulses through every meeting. The culprit? A culture where mistakes bring ridicule, feedback means public shaming, and people watch their backs instead of supporting each other.
One day, a new division manager arrives. She quietly audits the environment, noticing the patterns: employees hush each other, avoid eye contact when leaders speak, and only share safe, approved ideas. At her first town hall, she does something radical—she shares a story of a recent project she messed up, what she learned, and how her old team used it as a springboard, not a blacklist. The team tenses, uncertain.
Later that quarter, an employee risks admitting a missed target in a public meeting, bracing for blame. Instead, the manager thanks him for his clarity, asks what they can improve together, and invites others to share similar stories. Slowly, trust builds. Results improve not because people are shielded from mistakes, but because openness becomes safer than silence.
Workplace research backs this up. Cultures ruled by shame—where fear silences, blame festers, and mistakes mean humiliation—see higher disengagement, burnout, and even ethics violations. But when courage, curiosity, and learning are openly rewarded, organizations thrive.
If you’re part of a team, classroom, or community, spend the next week paying close attention to the cues: is fear of humiliation keeping people silent or covering up errors? Choose one opportunity to share something vulnerable and see who follows. Try rewarding risk and honest learning as much as outcomes. When a tough conversation is needed, separate actions from personal value; focus on what’s actionable and what’s possible to improve together. By modeling this shift, you open the door to a culture that grows through mistakes, not around them.
What You'll Achieve
You’ll dismantle barriers to innovation and teamwork, lower absenteeism and turnover, and foster a climate where people contribute—and learn—from their best and worst moments.
Grow a Culture of Courage—Not Fear and Blame
Assess your team or community for shame signals.
Look for patterns like public reprimands, gossip, favoritism, or people fearing to speak up. Note where mistakes become sources of humiliation instead of learning.
Identify at least one vulnerability you can model.
Share the story of a risk, a failure, or a tough lesson—with honesty and without spinning for applause.
Intentionally reward courage and learning, not just results.
When someone tries something new or admits a mistake, publicly value the effort and reflection—even if the outcome wasn’t a win.
Hold tough accountability conversations without shame.
Address problems directly, focusing on behavior and actionable next steps, never on the value or worth of the person.
Reflection Questions
- Where do you see shame signals—silence, secrecy, gossip—in your work, school, or team?
- How do leaders respond to mistakes—is learning or punishment the norm?
- When did you last openly admit a failure, and what happened next?
- What next step could you take to reward courage instead of just results?
Personalization Tips
- A business leader publicly thanks an employee for admitting a failed experiment and discussing what was learned.
- A coach uses a mistake during practice to model self-reflection, not blame.
- An art class celebrates brave attempts at new styles, even when results are messy or imperfect.
Daring Greatly: How the Courage to Be Vulnerable Transforms the Way We Live, Love, Parent, and Lead
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.