Why Quick Fixes Rarely Work—And How Real Change Follows Stages You Can’t Skip

Hard - Requires significant effort Recommended

When people want to improve—lose weight, break a habit, or recover from heartbreak—the world often tells them, 'Just do it.' But science repeatedly shows that change rarely happens in a single leap. Behavioral professors James Prochaska and Carlo DiClemente mapped out a model called the 'Stages of Change,' finding that every major shift runs through predictable steps: pre-contemplation, contemplation, preparation, action, and maintenance.

Consider someone struggling with drinking too much. At first, they might not see a problem (pre-contemplation), then gradually realize it's impacting their mood and work (contemplation). Only after weighing pros and cons, often for weeks or months, do they start stocking healthier drinks or calling a support group (preparation). True action—showing up to meetings, refusing drinks—takes shape slowly, and sustaining those changes (maintenance) is an ongoing battle, not a one-time achievement.

Research demonstrates that slipping back is normal, not a sign of failure. People cycle through these stages, sometimes getting stuck, sometimes moving ahead. Impatient advice like 'just eat healthier' or 'stop ruminating' misses the essential reality: readiness to act develops gradually. Awareness, reflection, support, and tiny repeated actions build the bridge from dreaming to doing.

Acknowledging what stage you're actually in, instead of what you wish, is the groundwork for success. Change isn't about one giant leap, but about learning which rung of the ladder you stand on right now, then climbing up one small step at a time.

Start by figuring out where you really are with your change—a bit stuck, thinking about it, or already acting? Write down why you want this, then pick something almost too easy for your next move (maybe one sentence a day if you’re starting to write again, or five minutes of tidying if it’s your space). Once a week, check your stage and notice even small shifts in motivation or behavior, whether forward or back. These subtle moves, repeated and tracked, are how real, sustainable change develops—without pressure to skip steps or rush yourself. Take one step forward now, no matter how tiny.

What You'll Achieve

You will learn to break down intimidating goals and avoid self-sabotage, gaining measurable progress in any area where you want to grow. Internally, you'll have more self-acceptance and patience, with less frustration over setbacks.

Move Through the Real Stages of Lasting Change

1

Pinpoint your current stage of change.

Identify whether you're in pre-contemplation (not thinking about change), contemplation (thinking seriously), preparation (planning), action (doing), or maintenance (sustaining). Be honest about where you really are rather than where you wish.

2

Clarify your present motivation.

Write 2–3 sentences about why you want to change this particular habit or pattern. Focus on personal meaning, not external pressure.

3

Set one tiny, concrete next step.

Choose something so doable you can't avoid it (e.g., 'I’ll write one sentence,' 'I’ll walk 5 minutes'). Small action, not grand plans, builds momentum.

4

Track your stage shifts over time.

Once a week, note which stage you’re at and how your feelings have shifted. Expect to cycle back and forth sometimes; this is normal and part of real change.

Reflection Questions

  • Which stage am I truly in regarding this change?
  • What is the smallest next step I could realistically commit to?
  • How do I react when I slip back a stage?
  • Who could help me reflect on my real progress?

Personalization Tips

  • A student moves from ignoring late assignments (pre-contemplation) to realizing it's a problem (contemplation), then creating a study plan (preparation), finally sticking with daily 10-minute reviews (action).
  • Someone wanting to quit smoking first denies the risk (pre-contemplation), then starts researching health impacts (contemplation), next throws out one old pack (preparation), and finally tells a friend for accountability (action).
Maybe You Should Talk to Someone: A Therapist, Her Therapist, and Our Lives Revealed
← Back to Book

Maybe You Should Talk to Someone: A Therapist, Her Therapist, and Our Lives Revealed

Lori Gottlieb
Insight 2 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.