Standing Up for Yourself Does Not Equal Being Selfish—It Might Save the Group

Hard - Requires significant effort Recommended

The fear of being 'too much'—or not enough—often silences people who contribute the most. It’s easy to confuse self-assertion with arrogance, but research on group performance and identity (see Amy Edmondson’s psychological safety studies) shows that teams flounder when members suppress their voices to avoid rocking the boat. When Running with Scissors’ chemistry falters, A.J. worries he’ll be tossed aside when Jude returns. After a heated dispute, he takes a risk: naming his skills, reminding the group of his record, and refusing to be quietly replaced as drummer. His stand is firm but fact-based. The group is forced to recognize his value and start an honest conversation about strengths and fit, rather than keeping decisions shrouded in competition or resentment. Rather than unravelling the team, his assertiveness saves it from drift and invisibility. The courageous act of claiming your seat is often precisely what keeps a performance group resilient.

Count your wins and be prepared to cite them—don’t let insecurity or comparison shrink you out of a team you’ve earned. Challenge doubts directly, ask for actionable feedback you can work with, and repeat your commitment to shared success loud enough for everyone to hear. It’s not selfish—it helps your whole group grow.

What You'll Achieve

You’ll increase your confidence, get noticed for your real strengths, and keep your role in any group secure without sacrificing your self-respect or the collective good.

Assert Your Role With Confidence and Evidence

1

Gather clear evidence of your contributions.

List your specific skills, hard work, and results—e.g., tracks you nailed, logistical duties, positive feedback.

2

Challenge threats to your value directly but calmly.

Speak up when others attempt to displace or minimize you: 'I believe I’m the right fit for this.' Give your grounded reasons.

3

Invite open discussion about strengths and improvement.

Ask for concrete feedback. Welcome suggestions for where and how to grow, but reject unnecessary or manipulative comparisons.

4

Reaffirm your commitment to group goals.

After conflict, anchor your position by restating your investment in collective success.

Reflection Questions

  • Where have I let self-doubt silence my real strengths?
  • When have I defended my value—what happened?
  • What feedback would help me grow without eroding my confidence?

Personalization Tips

  • A student is assigned a project and later someone tries to take credit—she points to her documented effort to defend her place.
  • A junior team member at work firmly reviews his results in a performance review, standing his ground against unfair criticism.
  • In a band or club, someone resists being quietly pushed aside when a former star returns, and shows with performance and presence why they belong.
Running with Scissors
← Back to Book

Running with Scissors

Augusten Burroughs
Insight 5 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.