Unlock the surprising influence of ‘relativity’ on your everyday decisions
Paula goes out to buy a new jacket. She spots three options: a simple $70 basic, a mid-range $110 version with an extra feature, and a $110 option with less functionality but fancier stitching. The third seems pointless, but it cleverly makes the mid-range one look like a great value in comparison. Paula almost skips the cheapest entirely, but pauses. Would she even consider the $110 jacket if the $110 decoy wasn’t there? Probably not. She leaves, jacketless, determined to review what she truly needs.
Later, her colleague raves about a new smartphone. Paula starts wanting one, but recalls how she enjoyed her current one before making comparisons. She puts her phone away, takes a breath, and finds a small sense of contentment.
Behavioral science shows we rarely judge value on its own—we default to comparing options that are easy to line up, especially when decoy options are planted to shape our choices. This habit extends beyond shopping, seeping into career, friendships, and even self-worth. Understanding relativity and the power of 'decoys' lets us reclaim our own priorities, not just the ones served up by marketers or social pressure.
The next time you're choosing between options, slow down and ask yourself which is the real reason you're leaning in a particular direction. Look for any option that seems to exist only to make another choice look better—a restaurant menu’s priciest entrée, a store’s oddly-designed laptop, or even your neighbor’s new car. Resist making a decision just by comparison and imagine picking your choice if it were the only thing available. Bring your attention back to your own needs. Try this when making your next shopping or life decision—if it feels uncomfortable, that’s a good sign you’re learning to choose by your standards, not others’ distractions.
What You'll Achieve
Develop independence from manipulative comparisons, resulting in greater contentment and more authentic choices. Internally, you’ll feel less envy and frustration; externally, you’ll spend and live with clearer priorities.
Spot and Defuse Decoys Shaping Your Choices
Look for artificial 'decoy' options.
When faced with three or more choices (in shopping, dining, etc.), see if any one seems to exist just to make another option look appealing—often it’s priced similarly but inferior in value.
Reframe decisions in absolute terms.
Instead of focusing on which item looks best compared to its neighbor, pause and ask yourself, 'Would I want this if it stood alone?'
Limit unnecessary comparisons.
Notice when you compare your possessions, achievements, or looks to others, and try to focus on your own values and needs.
Change your circle of reference.
If you find yourself trapped in unhelpful comparisons (e.g., feeling poor among wealthy friends), consciously choose different reference groups or contexts where you appreciate what you have.
Reflection Questions
- Are decoy options affecting your major or minor purchases this week?
- Where do you most often slip into unhealthy comparisons?
- How can you choose your reference points more intentionally?
Personalization Tips
- If you're choosing a menu item, skip over the most expensive dish designed to make others seem affordable.
- When buying a new laptop, base your choice on what you actually need, not just features that outshine another model.
- Notice how you feel after checking social media—are you comparing yourself to 'decoy' lifestyles?
Predictably Irrational: The Hidden Forces That Shape Our Decisions
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.