Why Instincts Can Betray You—and What Makes Snap Judgments Go Wrong
Plenty of people take pride in trusting their instincts, but even the sharpest intuition can be led astray. Art collectors, for instance, desperately want a statue to be real, so their emotional investment overrides their gut’s quiet alarm bells. Or imagine a young couple glossing over subtle signs of inflexibility or contempt in their marriage, because they’re caught up in the early “glow” of their relationship.
We’re not immune to these traps: sometimes we want something to be true so badly that we ignore the cold, subtle warnings our unconscious provides. External factors—like the prestige of a purchase, a group’s excitement, or the promise of a quick win—can all block or warp our instincts. Even experts fall in love with first impressions and then refuse to question them, as happened with art historians who missed clues about forged sculptures.
Psychologists call this motivated reasoning: our unconscious filters information not just for patterns or danger, but for what aligns with our desires, fears, and biases. Sometimes these biases hide because they’re so tied up in what we want, or because a strong interest drowns out quieter doubts. It’s easy to get blinded to faults in something—or someone—you love. The trick is to spot when your instincts are being overridden by hidden motives, to question what you want to believe, and to step back and reassess. No gut feeling is flawless, but reflecting on these pitfalls helps you avoid self-deception and learn from your mistakes.
Recall a moment your gut reaction missed the mark—maybe you misjudged someone’s intentions, or bought something too quickly only to regret it later. Dig into what clouded your judgment: was it your longing, a group’s excitement, or a fear of missing out? Jot down these situations and develop a simple checklist of emotional triggers that trip you up, so next time you’re in the moment, you can pause and challenge automatic assumptions. With practice, you’ll spot hidden motives faster and make sharper, more honest decisions.
What You'll Achieve
Better discernment by recognizing when instincts are unreliable, fewer costly mistakes, and stronger self-awareness to avoid repeating common pitfalls.
Detect and Challenge Automatic Biases in Decisions
List three situations where your gut was wrong.
Think of times when a first impression or snap judgment led to a mistake or misjudgment (e.g., judging a job candidate, friend, or product).
Analyze what interfered with your intuition.
For each, ask: Was I influenced by wishful thinking, desire, fear, stereotypes, or pressure to conform?
Identify hidden motives or biases.
Reflect on how emotions, stakes, or social context clouded your quick thinking or blinded you to warning signs.
Create a personal “bias checklist.”
Write down common triggers (e.g., wanting to impress, fear of missing out) to watch for when making rapid judgments.
Reflection Questions
- What personal motives most often distort my snap judgments?
- When am I most vulnerable to wishful thinking or bias?
- How can I create habits to pause and re-evaluate high-stakes decisions?
Personalization Tips
- A team leader overrates a job applicant because they remind them of a friend.
- You ignore doubts about a purchase because you want it to be ‘the one’.
- Overriding your gut to fit in with a group’s opinion.
Blink: The Power of Thinking Without Thinking
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.