The Ritual Trap: How Powerful Group Rituals Build Belief and When to Step Away

Hard - Requires significant effort Recommended

Picture yourself at the center of a group reciting a familiar mantra or performing a ritual. The room hums with energy, each voice lifting the next. Sometimes, it’s genuinely transformative—it launches a wave of motivation, joy, or hope. Other times, you suspect people are just going through the motions, wary of being the first to stop.

When you muster the courage to step away—choosing silence, or to skip a chant—you feel something subtle shift. Maybe it’s just an awkward silence, or maybe someone checks in, curious or defensive. The pause lets you feel your own boundaries more clearly and helps clarify what you actually value about the ritual.

Psychological research on ritual and performative language shows these practices can cement beliefs, bolster group energy, or even trap questioning minds. The healthiest groups treat ritual as scaffolding, not shackles.

The next time you’re asked to take part in a group ritual or shared mantra, pause to check in with yourself—do you want to participate, or do you feel pressure? Try opting out once, or voice your feelings afterward, and take note of the result. This is where you discover whether the ritual enriches your experience or reveals uncomfortable pressure—insight that can reshape your future choices.

What You'll Achieve

Stronger boundaries in community life, increased authenticity in group participation, deeper reflection on which rituals support your well-being versus those that don’t.

Set Healthy Boundaries Around Group Rituals and Mantras

1

Participate with intention, not out of habit.

Engage in group rituals or mantras only when they feel authentic and positive, not just because everyone else is doing it.

2

Debrief after each ritual or meeting.

Ask yourself whether the experience left you uplifted, drained, inspired, or pressured.

3

Experiment with exiting the ritual occasionally.

If leaving a ritual or choosing not to participate leads to shaming or exclusion, note the impact on your mood and self-esteem.

Reflection Questions

  • Do I feel energized or depleted after group rituals?
  • What value, if any, do I get from participating?
  • How do group leaders respond to non-participation?
  • How often do I reflect on the rituals before repeating them?

Personalization Tips

  • You opt out of a weekly affirmation circle at your club and notice who notices.
  • After a high-energy workout chanting session, you reflect on whether you felt truly connected or just hyped up.
  • You try out a friend’s faith tradition, joining a prayer, but decide not to take part in every ritual afterward.
Cultish: The Language of Fanaticism
← Back to Book

Cultish: The Language of Fanaticism

Amanda Montell
Insight 8 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.