Depth Wins Over Breadth: Commitment Leads to Genuine Freedom
You might think that the more options you keep open, the happier you’ll be. But research shows the opposite: having too many choices leads to endless second-guessing and shallower satisfaction. Deeper happiness comes from commitment—fully investing in one activity, relationship, or passion, rather than hopping from one thing to the next.
After years traveling country to country, chasing new experiences and new people, one adventurer realized that endless novelty left him empty. The depth of learning the language, building relationships, or mastering a craft only emerged when he finally settled in one place, said yes to fewer things, and let himself become truly committed.
This matches what psychologists call the “paradox of choice.” When we try to avoid missing out by doing a little of everything, we end up missing the joy, confidence, and meaning that only show up after months or years of focused practice. In school, work, and friendship, it’s the years spent digging, not gathering, that produce the truest rewards.
Spot the areas where your energy’s spread too thin—be honest about which hobbies, friendships, or projects leave you feeling fragmented. Pick just one to invest deeply in, setting aside others for now. Practice saying no—out loud or in writing—to the extras, letting any guilt pass. Direct your attention, time, and care into your top-choice commitment. You’ll discover an unexpected sense of freedom from narrowing your focus and giving your best where it matters most. Give it a real try this week, and notice what opens up for you.
What You'll Achieve
You’ll find greater satisfaction, confidence, and skill in the areas you prioritize. Internally, you’ll let go of guilt around 'missing out'; externally, you’ll build deeper expertise and stronger connections.
Say No to More, Yes to Meaningful Commitment
Pinpoint where you’re spreading yourself thin.
Make a list of ongoing activities, side projects, or social commitments. Circle any that drain your energy without deepening your skills or relationships.
Choose one area to go deeper, not wider.
Pick a job, hobby, or relationship, and make a specific plan to invest more focused time and attention (e.g., joining a club, regular practice, honest conversations).
Consciously reject less important options.
Write down—or say aloud—the things you’re declining so you can focus on your top choices. Notice any guilt, then remind yourself why you picked depth.
Reflection Questions
- Where in my life am I juggling too many options out of fear of missing out?
- Which area—relationship, work, hobby—would benefit from deeper commitment?
- What’s one project or person I will consciously invest more in this month?
- How do I handle saying 'no' to distractions or lower priorities?
Personalization Tips
- A musician devoting energy to mastering the piano instead of dabbling in a new instrument each month.
- A student saying no to extra clubs to focus on one cause they truly care about.
- A friend opting to nurture three close friendships rather than juggling a dozen loose acquaintances.
The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: A Counterintuitive Approach to Living a Good Life
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.