When Perfection Masks Pain: Why Authenticity Heals Where Control Breaks You

Medium - Requires some preparation Recommended

You wake up to yet another perfectly scheduled day, every minute filled with obligations—family expectations, study deadlines, or keeping up a certain image. Smiling at breakfast even as exhaustion tugs at your eyes, you find yourself laughing at a joke that’s not funny. It feels easier than explaining why you’re not okay. During lunch with friends, you pass up saying how lonely you feel, letting the group’s energy cover your restlessness. The fake smiles multiply, becoming a mask that feels impossible to remove.

While playing the role of perfect student, perfect daughter, or perfect friend, you begin to notice the sharp sting—it’s not just discomfort, but something deeper. After a tense family meeting, you slip into the bathroom and catch your reflection. The smile fades, revealing the ache underneath. For a moment, you wonder if anyone would notice if you stopped pretending. The next time the mask slips, you hesitate, considering whether to allow yourself just one honest expression.

Sharing your true feelings for the first time is terrifying. You text a friend and admit you’re not as put together as you seem. They reply with understanding, and a bit of relief crosses your chest. Over the next few days, you start noticing the difference between when you’re performing and when you’re actually yourself. The mask gets lighter; your chest feels less constricted.

This cycle of perfection and pretense is rooted in self-protection, often reinforced by controlling environments. According to psychological research, authenticity—allowing your internal state to match your external behavior—fosters resilience, genuine connection, and long-term mental health. It’s normal to fear the cost of honesty, but the benefits of living unmasked build over time.

Today, pay attention to each forced smile or moment you hide your real feelings. When you notice it, pause for a second and ask yourself what’s actually going on inside. Is it stress, sadness, or maybe annoyance? Don’t judge it, just notice it. As you go through your day, try to find one person you trust and share a little bit of that real feeling—tell them about a moment you kept hidden, and what you really felt. This honesty will feel strange at first, but you’ll soon notice your chest lighten, your mind grow clearer, and your relationships deepen. Let yourself take that small risk, and see how authenticity can start to heal.

What You'll Achieve

By practicing real emotional expression and noticing when you mask pain, you build the courage to show up authentically, leading to stronger relationships, less anxiety, and greater self-acceptance.

Notice Every Time You Fake a Smile Today

1

Track moments you pretend happiness.

Carry a small notebook or use your phone. Each time you force a smile, laugh on cue, or agree to something that doesn’t feel genuine, jot down the time and situation. Be honest about even the small instances, like at family meals or with friends.

2

Ask yourself what you’re actually feeling.

Right after recording, pause and identify what’s really happening inside—are you anxious, annoyed, disappointed, or sad? Try to name the feeling instead of dismissing it.

3

Share one real emotion with someone you trust.

Pick a safe person (a friend, a sibling, or even a therapist), and tell them about a recent time you hid your true feeling. Describe what you felt and why you didn’t show it.

Reflection Questions

  • What triggers you to hide your real emotions in daily life?
  • How does performing perfection make you feel after the moment passes?
  • Who is one safe person you could confide in honestly?
  • What are you most afraid others will think if you drop the mask?

Personalization Tips

  • At work, you catch yourself agreeing with a coworker even though you have a different idea—note your real reaction and consider speaking up next time.
  • During a family dinner, track whether you're laughing at jokes just to keep the peace. Later, confide in a sibling about how you really felt.
  • If you’re at school and feel out of place in a group, write down the impulse to shrink yourself, and try sharing the moment with a close friend.
Untamed
← Back to Book

Untamed

Glennon Doyle
Insight 1 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.