Near the end of his life an emperor borrowed a line from the theater

Hard - Requires significant effort Recommended

Near the very end of his notebook, after two decades of plague, war, and the deaths of people close to him, Marcus Aurelius reaches for a comparison from the theatre to explain what he has decided about his own eventual end. Mortal man, he writes to himself, you have lived as a citizen in this great city. What matter if that life is five years or fifty? The laws of the city apply equally to all. This is no tyrant or corrupt judge who dismisses you, but the very same nature that brought you in. It is like the officer who engaged a comic actor dismissing him from the stage. But I have not played my five acts, only three, the actor objects. True, comes the answer, but in life three acts can be the whole play.

He had reasons to need this comparison more than most people ever do. The plague that returned with Lucius Verus's armies from the east kept killing for years after it reached Rome. His own general, Avidius Cassius, once declared him dead and tried to seize the throne while he was still very much alive on campaign. His mother, he notes elsewhere with quiet gratitude, was fated to die young but still lived out her last years with him. Death, in other words, was not an abstraction Marcus theorised about from safety. It kept arriving at his door in specific, named forms.

His response, worked out across many entries, was to treat death as one more transformation nature performs, exactly like the ones that already happen constantly inside a living body: the death of one element becomes the birth of another, as he borrows from the philosopher Heraclitus, the death of earth is the birth of water, the death of water the birth of air. Elsewhere he compares dying directly to being born, calling both a mystery of nature, first a combination, then a dissolution, of the same elements, certainly no cause for shame. He even quotes an old line about leaves scattered by the wind, replaced each spring by new ones the forest puts out in their place, and applies it to entire generations of people, including whoever will one day mourn him.

What this buys him is not comfort in the ordinary sense, but a specific kind of freedom: since a shorter life is not an unfinished one, provided it was well acted while it lasted, there is no reason to keep postponing the acting well until some imagined fourth act arrives.

Take one thing you have been quietly postponing until later, a difficult conversation, a change you know you want, and ask what would happen if you treated today as though it might be your final act rather than a rehearsal for some future one. Practice describing death, at least once, in the plain terms Marcus Aurelius used, a dissolution of elements rather than an ending of everything you were, and notice whether the fear around it shifts at all. When someone close to you dies, let the grief run its course, but watch for the extra layer your mind wants to add, the judgement that this was a cosmic wrong rather than a natural change. Ask yourself, right now, whether the character you are currently playing is one you would be content to leave the stage as.

What You'll Achieve

You loosen the grip that fear of death and unfinished business has on your daily choices, so you stop postponing the conversations and changes that matter and can meet loss, your own or someone else's, without adding unnecessary judgement on top of the grief.

Live today as if it were final

1

Name what you are postponing.

Identify one thing you have been putting off until later, a difficult conversation, a change you want, and ask what would happen if you treated today as your final act rather than a rehearsal.

2

Practice the plain description of death.

Describe death, at least once, in the terms Marcus Aurelius used, a dissolution of elements rather than an ending of everything you were, and notice whether the fear shifts at all.

3

Let grief run without the extra judgement.

When someone close to you dies, allow the grief itself, but watch for the added verdict that it was a cosmic wrong, and set that layer aside separately.

4

Check the role you are currently playing.

Ask whether the character you are playing right now is one you would be content to leave the stage as, if the play ended today.

Reflection Questions

  • What are you currently postponing until some imagined later act of your life?
  • How does describing death in plain material terms change the way it feels to think about?
  • When you grieve, can you separate the loss itself from the added judgement that it was unfair?
  • If your life ended today, would you be content with the character you have been playing?

Personalization Tips

  • Someone diagnosed with a serious illness decides to finish a long-delayed reconciliation with a sibling rather than waiting for a more convenient year.
  • A person grieving a parent's sudden death catches themselves adding the thought that it was unfair, and gently sets that extra judgement aside from the grief itself.
Meditations
← Back to Book

Meditations

Marcus Aurelius
Insight 8 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.