Stop Believing Every Thought—Why Not All Your Mind’s Stories Deserve Attention

Medium - Requires some preparation Recommended

You've probably noticed that your mind loves to repeat certain stories at the worst possible times. Maybe you're walking into a new classroom or work project and your head fills with familiar words: 'I'm not ready,' or 'They're all better than me.' For years, you might have tried to outsmart those thoughts, convince yourself they aren’t true, or drown them out with positive quotes. Still, those old phrases always seem to come back right when you need confidence.

One trick, borrowed from evidence-based psychology, is to intentionally put a little distance between you and these thoughts—instead of letting them run the show. When you prefix a recurring self-criticism with 'I'm having the thought that…', it's like noticing a radio is playing in the background. Suddenly, you're the listener—not the performer. You start to see your thoughts as mental habits rather than breaking-news headlines.

Sound silly? The odd thing is, science shows this works even better if you take it further. Try saying the negative thought in a goofy voice, or sing it to the tune of 'Happy Birthday.' It won’t make the thought go away, but it turns down the emotional volume. You might chuckle, sigh, or just realize how often your mind replays the same unhelpful playlist.

The beauty of this approach—called cognitive defusion in ACT—is that it doesn’t require you to debate, suppress, or 'fix' your thoughts. Instead, you begin to treat them like passing clouds or spam email. This freedom to choose which thoughts to take seriously is one of the most liberating skills you can learn.

Next time an old, discouraging thought pops up—maybe when you catch your reflection or mess something up—notice it, and then say to yourself: 'I'm having the thought that…' and insert the phrase. If you're brave (and alone), sing that same phrase in your favorite cartoon character’s voice or to a catchy tune. Notice how the thought shifts or feels lighter. With practice, this distancing technique will help you see your thoughts for what they are—a stream of words—not absolute truths. Try it out the next time your mind grabs the mic.

What You'll Achieve

Reduce the hold of negative or anxious thoughts, improve your ability to focus, and experience less emotional reactivity to old mental habits. You'll build the foundation for self-acceptance, improved confidence, and flexible thinking.

Practice Defusion by Distancing from Unhelpful Thoughts

1

Catch a Recurring Negative Thought.

Write down one thought about yourself or your future that tends to show up when you're stressed ('I'm not good enough,' 'I'll fail').

2

Prefix with 'I'm Having the Thought That…'.

Every time the thought arises, repeat it to yourself prefixed by 'I'm having the thought that...' Notice if the thought feels less overwhelming or more like words than facts.

3

Sing or Silly-Voice Your Thought.

Experiment by singing the negative thought to a silly tune or imagining it spoken in a cartoon character's voice. Observe your feelings about the thought after you do this.

Reflection Questions

  • How can distancing myself from thoughts change my reaction?
  • Are there certain self-criticisms I notice most often?
  • What does it feel like when a thought is 'just a thought' versus a fact?
  • Which defusion tricks (prefix, singing, silly voice) help me most?

Personalization Tips

  • Before a big test, rewrite 'I'm going to fail' as 'I'm having the thought that I'm going to fail,' and see if it's easier to focus.
  • During a rough practice, catch the thought 'I'm a terrible athlete,' and replay it in your mind as a cartoon voice until it loses its punch.
  • When feeling left out with friends, add the prefix to 'Nobody likes me' and notice the difference in emotional intensity.
The Happiness Trap: How to Stop Struggling and Start Living: A Guide to ACT
← Back to Book

The Happiness Trap: How to Stop Struggling and Start Living: A Guide to ACT

Russ Harris
Insight 2 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.