Stop Copying and Start Documenting: How Beginners Beat Experts Online

Medium - Requires some preparation Recommended

The dominant advice online is to 'fake it until you make it,' but the most memorable creators often do the opposite. They reveal their learning process—showing failed first attempts, unvarnished doubts, and the micro-skills picked up along the way. Audiences find this highly relatable, and it builds long-term loyalty and trust.

Instead of creating polished, impersonal content that mimics experts, you put your phone on the table and narrate your next attempt at learning a guitar chord. The camera captures missed notes and laughter. Over time, you see not just improvement in your playing, but a growing community offering tips, commiserating, or simply cheering you on. The documentary approach is more inviting, less intimidating, and positions you as an authentic peer rather than a distant expert.

Behavioral science tells us that we’re wired to learn by watching stories unfold rather than from static lectures. By publicly reflecting on your progress, you motivate yourself to keep learning. You also build a rich archive that, years from now, you—or your community—can look back on as credible proof of growth. The documented journey is the new résumé, far more persuasive (and interesting) than a static credential list.

Today, select an area where you're learning, not performing—one where you don't have to pretend to be an expert. Share your experience openly with your community, showing the full reality: early struggles, mid-course corrections, and genuine reactions. Invite others to contribute advice or share their own learning curves. As you do, you’ll find each step documented not only helps you grow faster but lets others root for you and learn alongside you. Forget faking it; being a work in progress is your best asset. Put your learning in public and let the market see what’s real.

What You'll Achieve

Gain the confidence to try new things publicly, speeding up your learning through feedback and accountability. Expect to build a more loyal, forgiving, and encouraging audience or customer base.

Document Your Learning Instead of Faking Expertise

1

Pick one thing you’re actively learning.

Identify a process, challenge, or topic where you’re a true beginner—coding, gardening, public speaking, art.

2

Begin sharing your progress as it happens.

Use video, blog, audio, or photos to show daily or weekly steps, including wins, mistakes, surprises, and insights. Resist editing out the rough parts.

3

Ask your audience what they want to see next.

Involve viewers in your journey, inviting questions or feedback to shape your next steps and deepen engagement.

Reflection Questions

  • What learning journey am I hiding for fear of embarrassment?
  • How could sharing my process inspire or help someone else?
  • In what ways are beginner stories actually more compelling than expert tutorials?

Personalization Tips

  • A college student vlogs about learning to cook, sharing every burnt pan and small win.
  • A new remote worker publicly shares struggles adjusting to a structured routine, including missed alarms and scheduling pitfalls.
  • A first-year teacher documents lesson planning and asks older teachers for advice in their stories.
Crushing It!: How Great Entrepreneurs Build Their Business and Influence—and How You Can, Too
← Back to Book

Crushing It!: How Great Entrepreneurs Build Their Business and Influence—and How You Can, Too

Gary Vaynerchuk
Insight 5 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.