The One-Off Problem: Why News Media Is Addicted to the Sensational and Instant

Hard - Requires significant effort Recommended

Much of what cascades through your phone or browser is engineered to sell itself on a single click, not for long-term learning or value. This 'one-off problem' mirrors a historic phase in newspapers when publishers hawked each individual copy on the street, battling to grab attention through whatever wild headlines, rumors, or scandals would move units fastest. Today’s digital media world is stuck in the same rut: every article needs to shout and sell itself instantly or be swallowed up in the noise.

The long-term effect is a diet of fast, sugary stories that spike attention but leave little substance behind. Subscription-based or trust-driven journalism, the kind that builds deep relationships with readers, is becoming rare—driven out by 'free' models that rely on impulse rather than reliability. The brain learns to crave the next hit of surprise, rarely pausing for the reflection that meaningful improvement or civic learning actually requires.

Psychologists who study information overload warn that people surrounded by constant novelty struggle to separate what matters from what just distracts. Your best shield: support content that rewards patience, accuracy, and context, not the empty thrill of daily sensation.

This week, try stepping back from any news source or feed that draws you in with a new controversy every hour. Instead, put your financial and attention resources toward a curated, member-supported publication, even if small. Once a week, write or voice a summary of what genuinely useful, thoughtful content you consumed, as opposed to what just made you stop and stare. This isn’t just a smarter way to stay informed—it’s a defense against distraction and regret.

What You'll Achieve

You’ll cultivate discernment, reduce impulsiveness in your information diet, and grow into the kind of consumer whose values support reliable journalism and better civic outcomes. Expect longer attention span and more satisfying learning.

Cut Sensationalism by Demanding Substance and Subscription

1

Unsubscribe From Single-Click News Feeds.

For one week, avoid or unsubscribe from sources that deliver only sensational headlines without depth—no more breaking alerts from tabloid or clickbait apps.

2

Support a Quality Content Subscription.

Invest in at least one source that curates news for accuracy and context—a magazine, nonprofit newsletter, or a long-form journalism app.

3

Initiate Personal News Roundups.

Once a week, summarize for yourself or a friend the most valuable, substantive things you learned versus the most outrageous but unhelpful tidbits.

Reflection Questions

  • Which stories made a real difference in my life this week versus which just frustrated me?
  • What’s the emotional cost of being bombarded by single-use, sensational news?
  • How could my investment in quality information change the media ecosystem long-term?
  • Where am I currently complicit in rewarding empty sensationalism?

Personalization Tips

  • In a school club, debate which news stories would survive a subscription model—do they inform or just titillate?
  • Families: Start a group subscription to a trustworthy news outlet and discuss the difference in tone, content, and impact versus free viral stories.
  • On social media, regularly mute or hide sources that never follow up on their original stories.
Trust Me, I'm Lying: Confessions of a Media Manipulator
← Back to Book

Trust Me, I'm Lying: Confessions of a Media Manipulator

Ryan Holiday
Insight 7 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.