Why Agile Fails When Used as an Assembly Line—and What Actually Works
Many teams think they’re 'doing Agile' just because they work in sprints and fill their walls with sticky notes or online tickets. Yet, progress crawls, customer delight remains elusive, and teams still feel trapped by old waterfall thinking in new clothes. The root problem? Risks aren’t managed up front—work is still sequenced as a handoff: requirements, design, build, test, deploy. Agile ceremonies can’t save you if the fundamental questions about value, usability, feasibility, or business fit go unasked until it’s time to code, or worse, to launch.
Strong teams transform their practices by recognizing that these four risks must be explored and tested—quickly and together—long before sprint planning. They don’t just shout about cross-functionality; they live it, collaborating on rapid prototypes, sharing insights, and measuring progress against whether they’ve actually solved a meaningful user problem. Agile frameworks like Scrum or Kanban are only as helpful as the problem-solving culture behind them. It’s this mindset—tackling risks early, together, and iteratively—that sets apart the teams delivering real customer value from those endlessly polishing backlog items.
Next time you kick off a project or feature, take ten minutes to run through the four risks—value, usability, feasibility, and business viability—with your whole team. Invite everyone to air their doubts and brainstorm quick, messy solutions or prototypes together before anyone spends hours building or writing specs. Track your progress by the impact on the underlying problem, not by how many tasks you complete. It might feel different from just working through your backlog, but when your project wraps, you’ll see the difference in both results and morale. Challenge yourself to try this for even one new idea this week.
What You'll Achieve
Gain better foresight and confidence in your team's work, reduce setbacks and rework, and drive more value for users and the business by addressing what really matters early.
Move Beyond Agile By Tackling Risks Up Front
List the four key risks for every project.
For your next initiative, explicitly discuss value (will they use it?), usability (can they use it?), feasibility (can we build it?), and business viability (will it work for the business?). Write them down and discuss with your team at the start.
Prototype solutions collaboratively before sprinting.
Get product, design, and engineering together to generate and test ideas using quick prototypes—resist the urge to write full specifications up front or push to code immediately.
Measure progress by solved problems, not completed tickets.
Adopt measurable, user-facing outcomes as your primary metrics of progress, rather than story points or ticket closure rates.
Reflection Questions
- What risks am I frequently ignoring until it’s already too late?
- How can my team collaborate earlier and more honestly?
- What would it take for us to measure success by outcomes instead of completed tasks?
- Which risk do I personally tend to focus on—and what might I be missing?
Personalization Tips
- At work: Before diving into building a new tool, hold a risk-mapping session using the four types.
- In learning: Tackle tough homework by first sketching or trialing different approaches as a group.
- In volunteer projects: Check feasibility and relevance with the community before spending weekends building something new.
Inspired: How to Create Tech Products Customers Love
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.