The Planner and the Doer: Why Long-Term Goals Get Sabotaged by Instant Gratification
You wake up determined to exercise after school. By dinner, your resolve has wilted and your plans dissolve into a binge-watch session. Tomorrow, you promise, will be different. This classic tug-of-war is the struggle between your inner 'planner'—the forward-thinking part of you who sets goals—and the impulsive 'doer' who craves comfort right now.
Behavioral science calls this internal conflict the planner-doer problem. We genuinely want what's good for our future, but our attention, energy, and emotional state often betray us in the moment. Adam Smith noticed it centuries ago, and modern researchers explain it through overlapping frameworks: the present-bias in discounting future rewards, the powerful allure of immediate sensory cues, and our habit of underestimating future temptations. Commitment strategies—like Odysseus tying himself to the mast—work because they remove choices before the heat of the moment strikes.
Practice makes progress, not perfection. Each time you create a hurdle for your impulsive self, you tip the scale in your planner’s favor, allowing goals to survive the immediate onslaughts of tiredness, stress, or cravings.
Think of a long-term goal you've struggled to sustain. Ask yourself honestly what derails you and when those temptations hit hardest. Then, throw up a roadblock—move cues for temptation out of reach, create auto-pilot solutions, and enlist reminders or friends as backup. When you succeed, note the mental clarity or extra free time that emerges. It may feel odd at first, but each rule you set is a lifeline tossed from your future self to your present one—grab it.
What You'll Achieve
Improve your ability to achieve big goals by overcoming momentary urges, building up willpower 'muscle,' and reducing internal conflict.
Set Personal Rules to Overcome Short-Term Temptations
Identify one long-term goal you often fail to follow through on.
Is it saving money, sticking to a health plan, or managing study sessions?
Describe the specific temptation that derails you.
Write down where, when, and how this urge shows up.
Design a commitment strategy that blocks the temptation.
Examples: Move junk food out of reach, set an automatic savings transfer, leave your phone in another room.
Recruit accountability or set up reminders.
Tell a friend, use an app, or post a visual cue to reinforce your personal rule.
Reflection Questions
- What ‘doer’ temptations repeatedly sabotage your progress?
- How could a small commitment device change your default response?
- Who or what could help bring your planner back into charge?
Personalization Tips
- A student signs up for a morning class to force themselves awake and out of bed.
- A dieter keeps only healthy food in the house to avoid nighttime snacking.
- A freelancer automates monthly transfers to savings accounts to bypass daily spending temptations.
Misbehaving: The Making of Behavioral Economics
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.