Why Your Most Valuable Ideas Are Met With Silence—And How to Keep Going

Medium - Requires some preparation Recommended

All remarkable creative acts—whether in business, art, or personal life—begin with a burst of excitement, quickly followed by a long stretch of silence. The world is slow to see what you see. Even your closest allies might only shrug, or worse, try to talk you out of your wild experiment. At these moments, loneliness is less a warning sign and more a rite of passage.

Documenting your progress as you go—privately, without an audience—grounds your effort when applause doesn’t come. These notes, drafts, or photos build a bridge from idea to reality, capturing the intangible growth that unfolds before results are obvious. Eventually, when the time feels right, you can let one supportive figure into the process. But it’s crucial not to conflate early indifference with failure: history and studies of innovation show that every truly new idea has a period when it lives in obscurity or even resistance.

Psychological research into creativity and group dynamics shows that social proof—evidence others agree—lags behind originality. It’s only by persisting through the quiet years that exceptional work comes to life, and those who learn to navigate the lonely stretch are best prepared for the demands and attention that eventually follow.

Expect loneliness at the start and view it as normal rather than discouraging. Build a personal journal of your progress—no matter the medium—so you have proof of your forward movement and an anchor for your motivation. When ready, invite only one trusted person into your circle, someone who can offer honest, thoughtful feedback. By accepting this rhythm, your best work gets space to grow before it faces the outside world. Give yourself permission to keep moving even when it seems like nobody else cares yet.

What You'll Achieve

Strengthen emotional resilience, improve follow-through on projects, and develop strategies for pushing new ideas forward despite a lack of immediate feedback or support.

Endure the Lonely Early Stages of Breakthrough Work

1

Expect and accept initial loneliness.

Before sharing your new idea, remind yourself that silence or skepticism from others is normal, not a signal you’re wrong.

2

Document your progress for yourself.

Keep a private record—notes, a voice memo, or photo diary—detailing what you create and how you feel, so you have proof of your journey.

3

Limit feedback at first, then pick a trusted supporter.

After making some progress, share with one supportive person, not a crowd, and ask for honest reactions—not validation.

Reflection Questions

  • How did you react the last time your new idea was greeted with silence?
  • What do you gain by documenting your private progress?
  • Who could provide the honest feedback you really need—not just encouragement?
  • How will you reward yourself for sticking with something through its lonely phase?

Personalization Tips

  • A student invents a new study system for themselves and tests it out before telling classmates.
  • An employee pushes for a new process but keeps records until there’s tangible progress before engaging managers.
  • A writer drafts several chapters alone, sharing only with a quiet mentor after hitting a milestone.
Ignore Everybody: and 39 Other Keys to Creativity
← Back to Book

Ignore Everybody: and 39 Other Keys to Creativity

Hugh MacLeod
Insight 4 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.