Beware the Scarcity Mindset: Why Focusing Only on Hits Can Limit Growth and Creativity

Medium - Requires some preparation

From blockbuster movies to viral songs, most people believe that what’s most popular must be best—that if something doesn’t sell widely or make the top charts, it isn’t worth much attention. But chasing only 'hits' can be a trap. Stores, media, and even educational systems are set up to maximize what sells to the largest group, not necessarily what would benefit or inspire each individual. This leads not just to lost opportunities but to creative stagnation: everyone’s stuck with the same old menu, and real innovation gets buried.

Markets built solely on 'hits' ignore the hidden strengths of diversity. When resources are scarce—like shelf space or radio slots—there’s an incentive to cut options down to just what fits. But this mindset persists even when shelves become infinite or digital: we keep measuring success by comparison instead of impact or fit. Behavioral science explains that following the crowd is natural—it feels safe—but also that over time, it dampens learning and leaves valuable ideas on the table.

When you shift away from the scarcity mindset—where only big winners count—and start exploring small, overlooked options, you often find more meaning, satisfaction, and sometimes even big financial gains.

Today, pause whenever you feel yourself drifting toward the safe, popular choice—maybe a trending show, the best-selling snack at the store, or a group favorite for activities. Ask what actually matters most to you: is it uniqueness, personal enjoyment, or the chance to try something new? Pick just one situation and consciously choose a less common alternative, noticing how this changes the outcome and your feelings about the decision. With practice, you'll see that your best results may come from where the crowds aren’t looking.

What You'll Achieve

Break free from unhelpful conformity, unlock creative solutions, and experience more fulfilling choices that match your unique goals—not just what is sold as 'best.'

Challenge the Rules of Popularity in Your Decisions

1

Review three recent decisions influenced by popularity.

Think about cases—music, movie picks, project choices, even social group activities—where 'popularity' heavily swayed your final choice or where you defaulted to 'what everyone else is doing.'

2

Reframe criteria for value.

Ask: Does popularity really mean better for you? List alternative criteria: personal resonance, uniqueness, depth, or potential for learning.

3

Intentionally try an unpopular or overlooked option.

Pick one experience where you would usually default to the top-rated or most famous, and instead try a less-known alternative that appeals to you for another reason.

Reflection Questions

  • When have you missed out by following 'the crowd'?
  • What does 'best' actually mean in your context?
  • How could you re-define success or value outside of popularity?
  • Where are you limiting yourself by focusing only on common options?

Personalization Tips

  • A teacher assigns research topics and suggests extra credit for students who explore obscure or under-publicized events.
  • An entrepreneur investigates niche markets that competitors ignore, creating a best-selling side product.
The Long Tail: Why the Future of Business is Selling Less of More
← Back to Book

The Long Tail: Why the Future of Business is Selling Less of More

Chris Anderson
Insight 5 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.