Making Mindless Choices Feels Safer Than Fewer Hard Choices
Everyone wants choices—until too many or too complicated options turn small tasks into guessing games. If you’ve tried to buy train tickets online or sign up for services, you know the anxiety of picking the right ‘plan’ out of several, each with fine print. Sometimes you just quit or choose at random, hoping for the best.
Research in cognitive psychology shows our brains prefer a series of small, certain steps rather than big, ambiguous ones. The ‘scent of information’ theory says people keep clicking as long as each next choice feels easy and clear. It’s not about how many clicks it takes, but how straightforward each one is. One unambiguous click is better than a tough question every time.
Well-designed systems break tough choices into bite-sized steps and guide you with hints just when you need them. That’s not just considerate—it increases follow-through and trust. When the path is paved with easy, obvious steps, moving forward feels safe rather than stressful.
Start by finding the parts of your project where everyone gets stuck or takes too long to decide. Instead of lumping all the questions or options together, break them apart and show just one decision at a time. Use simple language and arrows, and if you know a step is confusing, put a short tip right where the user needs it. When you smooth the hard spots this way, your users will glide forward instead of pausing in confusion. Try breaking down your next big decision for others, and notice the difference.
What You'll Achieve
Increase user confidence, eliminate stress, and ensure follow-through on important tasks with less frustration and fewer errors.
Break Down Complex Choices into Simple Steps
Identify where users hesitate or stall.
Find the places in your process or page where users get stuck or second-guess their decisions. This is often at forms, subscription options, or when jargon pops up.
Split up complicated decisions into smaller, clear choices.
Instead of one big choice with lots of variables, break it down into a series of unambiguous steps. Use language and visuals to guide users with confidence.
Add timely, unavoidable help for tricky spots.
Where some thinking is unavoidable, add brief, clear guidance right next to the action (like ‘LOOK RIGHT’ painted at a crosswalk or a pop-up tip).
Reflection Questions
- Where do choices in your project become mentally taxing?
- How can you make each step in a process more obvious?
- What feedback have you received about confusing or tough decisions?
- What’s an example from your own life where a mindless path helped?
Personalization Tips
- For online forms, separate ‘Shipping Address’ and ‘Billing Address’ instead of one huge section.
- When voting on club matters, put each motion on its own page instead of combining issues.
- In recipe apps, show one cooking step at a time with a ‘Next’ button when instructions are complex.
Don't Make Me Think, Revisited: A Common Sense Approach to Web Usability (Voices That Matter)
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.