Avoid the Diversification Trap—Go Deep, Not Broad, to Achieve Mastery
It’s tempting—when you hit a wall at work, in a hobby, or during your studies, it almost feels productive to pick up something new. There’s a burst of excitement each time you join another club or download a new app to 'get organized.' But after a while, your calendar fills, and you notice you’re not actually making meaningful progress. You can play ten songs badly on guitar but have never practiced long enough to master one.
Behavioral economists call this the diversification bias: our brains prefer the variety of new beginnings over the slow grind of mastery. But the market, and personal satisfaction, reward depth far more than breadth. The analogy of the woodpecker—pecking twenty thousand times at the same tree to get a meal, instead of one tap on each of a thousand trees—isn’t just about motivation. It’s about results.
Research on learning and performance confirms this. People who succeed are those who learn to endure boredom or frustration and stay immersed until their skills compound. In business, brands that obsessively refine one offer often eclipse 'jack of all trades' companies.
If you feel scattered, use the 'pecking map' to visualize your real investment of effort. Most critically—resist the urge to run every time it gets hard. The real payoffs are always on the other side of sustained focus.
When you feel the itch to chase something new, pause and check whether you’re just dodging a hard but promising practice or project. Map out your commitments—see if your energy is splintered across too many things. Then, make a choice: for the next quarter, double down on one area that excites you, even if it’s not the easiest. Let go of some side projects with kindness, and keep digging on a single path until you land that real result. Try tracking your time and progress for these 90 days and see how your expertise and confidence change. The difference is clearer than you’d think.
What You'll Achieve
Experience faster mastery and deeper satisfaction by concentrating on a single pursuit long enough to achieve visible, meaningful results, rather than scattering your effort.
Choose One Tree and Keep Pecking
Resist the urge to start something new every time things get hard.
Reflect for a week before committing to any new activity or major project; ask, am I avoiding a Dip in something else?
Map your main pursuits on a page.
Draw a visual—like a set of trees or columns—showing how much time you’ve invested in each area over the past month.
Pick one focus to intensify for 90 days.
Pick the pursuit that most excites and challenges you and explicitly double your weekly investment there, cutting back on side projects.
Reflection Questions
- What projects have I started but dropped at the first sign of difficulty?
- What might I be running from by starting something new?
- Which single pursuit, if doubled down on, would have the biggest impact on my progress?
- How do I measure my own depth versus breadth, and which do I value more?
Personalization Tips
- Instead of switching from guitar to piano after a month of struggle, stick with guitar till you master a song you love.
- At work, refuse new committees so you can deliver a significant result on your main project.
- As a parent, keep supporting your child in one extracurricular long enough for them to build real skill, not just circulate through activities.
The Dip: A Little Book That Teaches You When to Quit (and When to Stick)
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.