Don’t Fall for Random Streaks—Why Your Brain Sees Patterns Where None Exist

Hard - Requires significant effort Recommended

In the thick of a basketball game, the crowd roars every time a player lands a string of shots, convinced the athlete is 'on fire.' The belief in streaks, or 'hot hands,' is emotionally gripping. But when scientists sifted through years of pro basketball statistics, a surprise emerged: players were just as likely to miss after a streak of hits as after misses. The pattern was a mirage. The same error appears when students try to guess quiz answers, investors try to time the market, or shoppers swear their lucky numbers are onto something big.

Why do smart minds make this mistake? Deep inside, our dopamine neurons crave predictability, reward, and the thrill of discovery. When faced with randomness—like a coin flip or the bounce of a basketball—they search for meaning where there truly isn’t any. In one study, even rats outperformed Yale undergrads in a task where placing food was random: the animals simply went for the higher probability location every time, while the students wasted effort looking for patterns that didn’t exist.

Learning to recognize—and challenge—the illusion of streaks is a crucial step toward better decisions in everything from sports to investing to daily choices. The urge to spot patterns is ancient, but it doesn’t always serve you in the modern world.

Next time you feel certain a streak is forming, stop and ask how much of that belief is grounded in hope, anxiety, or excitement rather than data. Take a deliberate moment to tally outcomes—whether quiz results, game wins, or market swings—and see if there’s any real foundation to your hunch. Challenge your brain’s love affair with patterns and keep a journal of so-called streaks for a week; you might find that most are random after all. By practicing skepticism in small ways, you’ll start to guard against impulsive leaps in much bigger decisions.

What You'll Achieve

Develop stronger critical thinking and emotional control by recognizing—and reducing—your own bias to see patterns in random outcomes. This boosts decision quality and protects you from costly errors.

Question Apparent Trends and Sharpen Your Skepticism

1

Ask for Evidence Before Trusting a Streak.

When you notice a 'hot hand' or winning streak—whether in sports, investing, or daily luck—pause and gather real data instead of anecdotes.

2

Remind Yourself of Randomness.

Even professionals, like NBA all-stars or stock traders, experience runs due to chance more often than skill. Challenge your impulse to assign meaning to every burst of success or failure.

3

Track Your Own Streaks.

For one week, keep a tally of events you think are 'streaky'—moments of repeated wins/losses—and note whether you can find any logical explanation or if they could just be random.

Reflection Questions

  • When have you acted on a 'lucky streak' only to be wrong?
  • What makes random outcomes so compelling to believe in?
  • How could you use skepticism to improve decision-making in games or investments?
  • Are there domains in your life where you might be seeing patterns that aren’t real?

Personalization Tips

  • A student reviews quiz scores and finds that good days alternate with bad ones, without any real change in studying.
  • A basketball fan tracks shot-by-shot field goals to check if 'hot hands' actually do occur.
  • An investor resists buying into a rising stock solely because it went up three days in a row.
How We Decide
← Back to Book

How We Decide

Jonah Lehrer
Insight 4 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.