Measurement Beats Guesswork—Track What’s Really Spreading, Then Optimize or Kill It

Medium - Requires some preparation Recommended

It’s easy to fall in love with your own ideas, but meaningful impact comes from tracking what works outside your own bubble. Direct marketers and successful startups know this: they measure everything—what gets shared, who returns, which details get people talking. Zara, the fashion retailer, rotates clothing lines every few weeks based on what’s selling, not what some manager predicts. Google famously obsesses over tiny user feedback, using real data to keep their homepage uncluttered and user-focused.

The toughest part is letting go: ideas that don’t click with real people, no matter how clever they seem, are quietly retired. Discarded rapidly, not left lingering to drag down the brand or drain enthusiasm. This discipline of testing, learning, and ruthless optimization is a hallmark of companies that consistently create ‘Purple Cows’—and it’s a habit anyone can borrow.

Start by choosing a single, easy-to-track signal that shows your work is catching on—shares, new sign-ups, returning users, whatever fits. Reach out to real people, not just your friends, and see who genuinely engages and talks about it. Notice what draws in real enthusiasm, then make those features bigger and bolder. Just as importantly, get comfortable dropping what falls flat, even if you like the idea yourself. Repeat the process and watch your impact grow. Choose something to measure this month and let the results guide your next move.

What You'll Achieve

Become more objective, less attached to pet ideas, and more willing to do what works. Build a continuous feedback-and-iteration cycle so your best ideas get better and your worst don’t hold you back.

Measure, Refine, or Drop What Isn't Remarkable

1

Pick one clear metric to track early reactions.

Decide on an observable action—number of shares, sign-ups, referrals, comments, or repeat use—that indicates real interest from your target group.

2

Get fast feedback from actual users or viewers.

Don’t just rely on internal opinions or assumptions; ask real people and look for immediate engagement or indifference.

3

Iterate what works and cut what doesn’t.

Double down on features or ideas that generate excitement; if something falls flat, remove or replace it quickly instead of hoping it will catch on later.

Reflection Questions

  • Am I tracking real reactions, or just guessing what people like?
  • What does actual user data show about what’s working?
  • Where am I letting personal attachment cloud my priorities?
  • How could I experiment with faster cycles of feedback?

Personalization Tips

  • In a school club, run a poll to see which event ideas get actual signups, not just likes.
  • For a product launch, watch which social media posts get genuine shares rather than just paid reach.
  • In family planning, notice which routines make everyone genuinely happier week after week—then focus there.
Purple Cow: Transform Your Business by Being Remarkable
← Back to Book

Purple Cow: Transform Your Business by Being Remarkable

Seth Godin
Insight 4 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.