Turn Opportunities into Precise Actions with Importance vs. Satisfaction Analysis

Medium - Requires some preparation Recommended

A ride-sharing startup exploded in popularity almost overnight, not because it had the flashiest app, but because it solved needs that really mattered and weren’t being met. People disliked late arrivals, opaque fares, and rude drivers in traditional taxis—but those problems persisted for years. By systematically surveying users, the team discovered these complaints were universally high-importance but low-satisfaction. They mapped out all possible needs for getting a ride—speed, cost, safety, comfort—and plotted them on a basic grid. High and unmet? That’s where they focused the bulk of their engineering and marketing.

When users opened the new app, real-time maps, driver ratings, and clear price estimates made them feel instantly more at ease. The company resisted the urge to add less-essential features until their big user complaints were reliably solved. As a result, customers flocked to the service and rarely looked back.

This process isn’t just for high-tech services. Any business, club, or personal project can use the “importance vs. satisfaction” method as a simple visual tool to find leverage: plot, look for gaps, and use your time and creativity on what truly matters. Not only does it reduce wasted effort, but it also keeps teams aligned and on track.

Take the time to ask for honest ratings—what do your users, friends, or teammates truly care about, and how happy are they with what’s available now? Draw a quick grid and plot those answers. The areas that stand out—most important and least satisfying—are where you’ll find your biggest wins. Make one test improvement in that zone, show it to a few real users, then refine before you invest heavily. This disciplined, visual approach is a sure way to spend energy where it will actually pay off.

What You'll Achieve

Boost effectiveness by zeroing in on what creates the most value, making resource allocation and prioritization more objective and ensuring that improvements matter to the people you serve.

Plot and Score Needs to Reveal Biggest Leverage

1

Survey or interview users about each feature’s importance.

Ask them to rate, on a simple scale, how essential each need or function truly is to them.

2

Assess user satisfaction with current solutions.

For every high-importance function, ask how happy they are with existing products or workarounds.

3

Graph these needs to find high-importance, low-satisfaction targets.

Map points so that the vertical axis is importance and horizontal is satisfaction—features in the top left (high need, unmet) are the most powerful places to focus.

4

Design and test solutions aimed at needs with the biggest 'gap.'

Create quick prototypes or simple mockups focused only on these leverage points and gather user feedback before investing further.

Reflection Questions

  • Where am I wasting effort on low-impact improvements?
  • How do I gather honest data about both importance and satisfaction from my users or stakeholders?
  • What small, high-leverage experiment could I run this week based on these findings?

Personalization Tips

  • A school principal surveys teachers on which administrative tasks cause the most frustration and then graphs the results to decide where to streamline processes.
  • Freelancers ask their clients which aspects of service matter most and check satisfaction, building new offers around the biggest 'gaps.'
  • At home, a family lists daily chores, rates which are hardest, and picks one area to fix with a new system.
The Lean Product Playbook: How to Innovate with Minimum Viable Products and Rapid Customer Feedback
← Back to Book

The Lean Product Playbook: How to Innovate with Minimum Viable Products and Rapid Customer Feedback

Dan Olsen
Insight 4 of 9

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.