Algorithms and Data: Trust Numbers Over Gut Instinct for Smarter Decisions
We love to think we’re great decision-makers, but countless studies show otherwise. When choosing employees, investments, or even day-to-day priorities, people naturally fall prey to mental shortcuts: we anchor on first impressions, remember vivid events, and feel overconfident in our predictions. Algorithms—structured decision rules built from data—repeatedly outperform our best judgments in domains from hiring to medicine. For example, a simple math-based hiring rubric can beat interviews by 25%. The more complex your environment gets, the more important it is to augment human smarts with objective data and algorithmic guidance. This doesn’t mean ignoring your experience or hunches, but using numbers to balance biases, uncover patterns, and drive better outcomes. In a world awash with information, your ability to measure and model, not just guess, becomes a superpower.
Pick a routine decision that usually feels like guesswork—maybe who to invite to a meeting, what to prioritize in your tasks, or which students might need extra help. Decide what measurable factors really matter, then collect and log data honestly for a few rounds. Try using a simple formula or checklist to shape your next choice and see if it predicts results better than instinct alone. Over weeks, reflect on how much clearer, fairer, and more repeatable your decisions can become with this blended approach. Give numbers a seat at the table—you might be surprised by what you learn.
What You'll Achieve
Reduce the sway of bias and habit in your decisions, build repeatable processes, and feel more confident you’ve made the best call with available evidence.
Blend Hard Data With Human Judgment
Identify a regularly repeated decision.
Pick one process in your work, school, or daily life where you typically rely on intuition—like hiring, budgeting, or scheduling.
Gather relevant data each time.
Commit to tracking specific, objective metrics for a set period, such as applicant scores, time spent, or outcomes achieved.
Use or create simple rules or algorithms.
Set up a checklist, rating formula, or automatic tool (spreadsheet or app) to combine the data and suggest a recommended action.
Compare and reflect on outcomes.
Once you have results, compare them to what would have happened using only your gut. Record surprises and lessons learned.
Reflection Questions
- Where do you most rely on intuition—and how often has it failed you?
- What data could bring clarity to a tough choice you face?
- How might you start using simple algorithms in your life?
- Do you fear that numbers could override your expertise—or that they could free it?
Personalization Tips
- A hiring manager trials an online aptitude test as a pre-screen for applicants, then monitors which hires perform best a year later.
- A student logs hours spent on different study methods and compares grades to see what actually works.
- A shop owner tracks promotions and sales numbers to discover which offers bring repeat customers.
Exponential Organizations: Why New Organizations Are Ten Times Better, Faster, Cheaper Than Yours (and What To Do About It)
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.