The Power of Polarization—How Not Trying to Please Everyone Attracts Your True Fans

Medium - Requires some preparation Recommended

It’s tough to let your true personality shine when there’s a risk you won’t fit in. In high school, the author was the 'awkward nerd,' the easiest target. Years later, that same quirky, honest style became the reason thousands of customers bought his work, not just what he was selling. As he started letting his real character show up—in newsletters, videos, and customer notes—something shifted. People responded to his awkward jokes and open geekiness. Some bailed early, but those who loved his style stuck around, spent more, and brought their friends.

Other examples pop up all over: Marie Forleo worried about seeming too wacky, but her goofiness made her a worldwide business superstar. A British entrepreneur built a tiny company that landed Olympic contracts because people liked his blunt, no-nonsense approach. Meanwhile, competitors who tried to be everything for everyone faded into the background, buried by blandness.

Hiding your quirks or strong beliefs only holds you back. Instead, choose an aspect of yourself—whether it’s your sense of humor, taste in books, or a strong stance on sustainability—and let it shine through in everything you create or share. You’ll polarize some people, but the ones who stay will become your true supporters, talking about you in ways that boring or safe competitors never inspire. Give people a reason to love you, and don’t sweat the folks who don’t. Try it out this week and watch who lights up when they see what you really stand for.

What You'll Achieve

Attract more loyal supporters, deepen trust, and create more meaningful connections, while freeing yourself from the exhaustion of trying to please everyone.

Lean Into What Makes You Uniquely You

1

Pinpoint an aspect of your personality or style that stands out.

Think of behaviors, views, or tastes that make you a little different (for example, quirky humor, direct communication, or unusual hobbies).

2

Infuse that trait into your work or messaging.

Write a blog post, make a video, or just change the tone of your emails to reflect your authentic self. Don’t filter or dilute what you love or believe in.

3

Openly state a position on an issue or preference.

This might mean supporting a cause, poking fun at industry norms, or declaring the small quirks you love.

Reflection Questions

  • What unique aspects of your style or beliefs are you hiding?
  • Have you ever tried to be neutral just to avoid criticism?
  • Who are your favorite creators, and what makes them memorable?
  • What would happen if you let your true self show in your next project?

Personalization Tips

  • A teacher with an offbeat sense of humor decorates their classroom in comic book style and lets students help pick themes.
  • A jewelry maker who loves bold colors tells customers, 'I don’t make beige. If you want beige, try Etsy.'
  • A science club adviser publicly supports climate activism, knowing it’ll draw students who care about big issues.
Company Of One: Why Staying Small Is the Next Big Thing for Business
← Back to Book

Company Of One: Why Staying Small Is the Next Big Thing for Business

Paul Jarvis
Insight 5 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.