Why psychological safety—being able to call out problems—supercharges team performance under stress

Medium - Requires some preparation Recommended

You’ve probably seen it yourself: in some groups, pointing out a problem gets you eye rolls or worse. In others, the person who sees the issue—early—is greeted like a hero. In one high-pressure engineering team, a habit emerges of opening every meeting with 'What’s not working?' A junior member nervously highlights a confusing message in the build instructions; instead of annoyance, the lead engineer says, 'Fantastic catch. Let’s fix it.' The mood shifts from tense compliance to eager problem-solving. Getting ahead of the issue means fewer emergencies later, and the whole team trusts that honesty isn’t just tolerated—it’s expected.

This feedback loop means that when a silent crisis builds (maybe parts are vanishing, or a subtle safety risk appears), anyone feels empowered to name it, regardless of their 'rank.' The result? Disasters get averted in the planning room, not after costly breakdowns. Research led by Amy Edmondson and others shows that teams with high psychological safety out-innovate rivals, endure greater stress, and bounce back faster—especially when every decision is high stakes. When people don’t fear being ‘blamed’ for raising ugly truths, collective intelligence and actual safety soar.

Start your next team check-in by specifically asking what worries people, and honor the honesty that comes out, even if it slows things down. When someone calls out a gap or mistake you missed, thank them and address it rather than defending yourself. Every time you model warmth in the face of criticism, you tell the whole team it’s safe to surface problems fast. Give this approach a sincere try—your group’s performance and trust will skyrocket as a result.

What You'll Achieve

Build high trust, cognitive diversity, and a capacity to resolve problems quickly—even under unusual stress or competition.

Model Honesty—Celebrate 'Bad News First' Reporting

1

At every meeting, ask for concerns before positive updates.

Kick off by inviting the team to mention the largest risks or frustrations they see, and thank them for raising red flags.

2

Express appreciation for candor.

Explicitly reward those who bring up uncomfortable or unpopular truths, ensuring transparency remains safe.

3

Practice non-defensive responses to criticism.

When someone points out an oversight, respond with openness: 'You might be right, let's investigate immediately'.

Reflection Questions

  • When was the last time you thanked someone for raising a problem that made work harder—not easier?
  • How do you usually react to bad news or criticism in front of a group?
  • What signals does your team see that psychological safety really matters?

Personalization Tips

  • A band leader makes time for everyone to voice what isn’t working in practice.
  • A teacher thanks a student for flagging a confusing instruction, even if it disrupts the class flow.
  • A manager deliberately invites the shyest team member to share concerns before wrapping up a meeting.
Liftoff: Elon Musk and the Desperate Early Days That Launched SpaceX
← Back to Book

Liftoff: Elon Musk and the Desperate Early Days That Launched SpaceX

Eric Berger
Insight 4 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.