Why Emotional and Social Jobs Outrank Raw Function in Value Creation

Medium - Requires some preparation Recommended

It's easy to assume customers only want faster, cheaper, or more powerful solutions. But when you step back for a closer look, you’ll often discover emotional or social motivators sitting quietly behind practical requests. A young designer once thought people wanted a more efficient water bottle, but interviews kept uncovering stories about feeling motivated at the gym or being seen as a 'trendsetter' among friends—that sense of identity turned out to be far more important than the no-spill lid or easy-grip handle.

In many product launches, a seemingly minor brand detail—like the color or story behind a logo—becomes a talking point, not because it works better, but because it lets people feel connected, stylish, or even just 'in the know.' These emotional and social jobs often drive purchase decisions, loyalty, and word-of-mouth far more than performance specs.

For example, an expensive coffee shop doesn’t necessarily win on taste. Instead, customers enjoy how sitting in a trendy space a few times a week makes them feel—sophisticated, part of a creative crowd, or just comforted by the familiar sounds and smells. The environment, the experience, and how it makes someone feel about themselves often outweigh the product itself.

Psychology frameworks such as Maslow’s hierarchy hint at this phenomenon: once basic needs are met, we quickly turn to the need for belonging, esteem, and self-actualization. In business, understanding these deeper motivations helps break away from generic claims about features or price and opens up opportunities to deliver something both memorable and meaningful.

To get started, sit down with your team and write out every possible job your customer has, going far beyond the obvious. Challenge yourself to ask 'why?' repeatedly—why does this matter, really? Don't settle for 'saves time' or 'better quality'; instead, hunt for what people really crave, like feeling trusted or admired. Once you've mapped those emotional and social jobs, pick one product or feature and tweak it to address a hidden feeling your customer wants. Notice how even small changes in messaging or design can create impact in ways numbers alone can’t show. Give these steps a test run the next time you brainstorm solutions.

What You'll Achieve

By learning to see beyond surface tasks, you’ll cultivate deeper empathy and insight, resulting in products or solutions that connect powerfully with how customers wish to feel or be seen. This leads not only to improved customer loyalty and satisfaction, but also a clearer differentiation in competitive markets.

Zoom Past Surface Needs to Uncover Hidden Motivations

1

List every job your customer is trying to accomplish.

Begin by mapping out all the tasks or problems your customer wants solved. Don't just focus on the obvious functional ones; dig for what they desire on a deeper level.

2

Ask 'Why?' at least three times for each job.

For every job, question why it’s important. This uncovers social motivations (like respect from others) or emotional drivers (like feeling safe, proud, connected), rather than just surface needs.

3

Identify which jobs are emotional or social.

Separate jobs that are about how someone wants to feel or be seen from those that are strictly about getting a task done. Notice patterns and rank how often emotional or social jobs show up.

4

Rework one offering to target an emotional or social job.

Adjust your product or service—even a simple feature or packaging—so it directly helps customers feel a certain way or achieve a desired social perception.

Reflection Questions

  • What emotions or social goals might be hiding behind my customers’ requests?
  • How does my current product or service help customers feel about themselves?
  • Have I ever overlooked what really matters to my audience because I focused only on function?
  • What’s one subtle way I could address an emotional or social need in my next project?

Personalization Tips

  • A high school student designs a class project not just for a grade, but to impress peers and teachers.
  • A clinic introduces a warm, welcoming lobby to reduce patient anxiety, not just check them in efficiently.
  • A parent chooses a birthday gift that makes their child feel like the star of the day.
Value Proposition Design: How to Create Products and Services Customers Want
← Back to Book

Value Proposition Design: How to Create Products and Services Customers Want

Alexander Osterwalder
Insight 1 of 8

Ready to Take Action?

Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.