Hire For Problem-Solving, Not Just Credentials or Culture ‘Fit’
Smart teams don’t just look for degrees or a polished résumé—they search for people who make others better by solving real, messy problems. A food bank needed a new logistics manager, but instead of just asking about prior warehouse roles, they set up a mock crisis: supplies were late, weather was changing, and volunteers were short-handed. One candidate calmly gathered team input, tested a new scheduling tool on the spot, and made a breakthrough. Another listed impressive credentials but froze without a prescribed plan.
Other teams found hidden talent by noticing unusual backgrounds: a student who played jazz piano turned out to be an unstoppable data analyst, making connections others missed. A recruiter noticed this pattern and added questions about music and improvisation to the interview process, broadening the pool of excellent problem-solvers.
Behavioral hiring research shows that focusing on core thinking skills and adaptability, rather than traditional 'best fit' or GPA, leads to more innovative, resilient teams—especially in fast-changing environments.
Next time you interview or welcome someone into your group, ask about a real-life problem similar to what you face, and listen closely for their thought process—not just their pre-packaged answers. Dig into odd hobbies or side projects to see if new skills can match your needs. Seek feedback from everyone involved, even those outside the official process—you might be surprised by who shines and what fresh ideas enter your team.
What You'll Achieve
Attract a broader, more creative range of talent; reduce bias and increase true capability; build teams that keep innovating as challenges evolve.
Go Beyond Resumes To Uncover Real Strengths
Create Scenarios That Test Problem-Solving.
During interviews, give candidates a real-world challenge similar to what your team faces. Look for their process, curiosity, and creativity—rather than just the 'right answer.'
Probe Unusual Experiences Or Passions.
Ask about side projects, hobbies, or cross-disciplinary work. Notice how candidates connect their unique skills to your needs, even if on paper they don’t seem to fit.
Value Recruiter And Team Feedback Equally.
Gather input from everyone who meets the candidate, not just managers. Include recruiters, peers, and cross-functional team members to ensure a broad perspective.
Reflection Questions
- What’s missing from your usual hiring or onboarding questions?
- When has someone from an unexpected background contributed key insights?
- Are you too focused on likability rather than effectiveness?
- Who on your team surprises you with creative solutions?
Personalization Tips
- A student club screens new volunteers by having them brainstorm how to improve an upcoming event.
- A neighborhood group invites people to share unrelated hobbies and sees who suggests surprising solutions.
- A hiring manager pays attention to a candidate’s musical background for a data-heavy job, seeking creative leaps.
Powerful: Building a Culture of Freedom and Responsibility
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.