Why Pivoting Beats Perfection—Survival Demands You Abandon ‘Your’ First Idea
Startup after startup in Silicon Valley, from Zimride to what became Lyft, and AirBed & Breakfast to Airbnb, began as something nearly unrecognizable from their later global success. The founders weren’t wedded to their first drafts; they experimented with countless peripheral projects and let go of ideas—even promising ones—at the drop of a hat. This practice isn’t just luck. Academic research calls it ‘effectuation’—a mindset where entrepreneurs act with the means at hand and remain ready to change course as soon as new reality emerges. Studies show that the most durable organizations are those whose teams get over sunk cost bias (the tendency to stick with investments simply because you’re already committed), and instead pivot quickly toward new evidence or opportunity. This is less about being flighty and more about recognizing when stubbornness serves you and when it's poison.
Over time, those who master the art of the pivot—not just in business, but in academia, science, and art—learn to see changes in direction as steps toward mastery, not scratches off a scoreboard. Ironically, the urge to 'get it right' from the jump is what keeps most projects small or stillborn.
Dig up all the rough starts and false trails you’ve collected (to do this right, don’t judge the list). Next, think back to each moment it made sense to turn a different direction, and feel for any pang of regret or stubborn pride—let that go. Then, for your current project, challenge yourself to honestly assess if it’s momentum or just momentum bias (that urge to not look like a quitter). If not, frame a pivot as a badge of wisdom. This keeps you agile and, in the end, much more likely to succeed despite early stumbles.
What You'll Achieve
Achieve greater adaptability by loosening emotional ties to initial ideas, increase your resilience to change, and maximize success by switching tracks with confidence.
Embrace Pivots as Part of the Journey
List every ‘side project’ or initial draft you’ve started.
Capture even the most half-baked or abandoned ideas, not just polished or launched ones.
Identify the moments when the original idea faltered.
Note whether the struggle was due to market size, technology, timing, or passion fizzling out.
Separate emotional attachment from current opportunity.
Ask yourself: Am I sticking to this plan because it’s truly the best, or just because I’ve invested so much time in it already?
Frame changes as progress, not failure.
Reinforce to yourself and your team that adapting, even radically, is a marker of wisdom—not surrender.
Reflection Questions
- What idea or project have you stayed attached to, despite poor results?
- What’s the hardest part of admitting a pivot is needed—for you or your group?
- How would your success rate change if you saw pivots as progress?
Personalization Tips
- If your science fair project isn’t working, be willing to switch hypotheses—even if you’ve already built half the model.
- During a club campaign that isn’t getting traction, brainstorm new directions instead of doubling down on what's not working.
The Upstarts: How Uber, Airbnb, and the Killer Companies of the New Silicon Valley Are Changing the World
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.