How Playful Brainstorming Outperforms Standard Meetings for Big Ideas
After missing a product deadline, a small tech team was desperate for a fresh approach. Their meetings used to start with a round of updates and polite critiques, but the energy sputtered out fast. Then, one Thursday, the group’s lead decided to post ground rules on the whiteboard—no criticism, all ideas welcome, build on each other’s thoughts, and try for 100 ideas in 45 minutes. She stacked the table with plastic toys, half-eaten snacks, and weird coffee mugs from home. At first, the group fidgeted, unsure if it was a joke. Then, as the first truly ridiculous ideas got a laugh, everyone leaned in.
Ideas flew—most silly or clearly impossible, but the mood shifted from anxious to energized. Someone drew a bizarre diagram of a two-level lunch tray. Another piled three highlighters into a “multi-pen.” One designer riffed on a pasta dispenser, quickly sketching an adjustable portion scoop. By the end, more than 70 ideas crammed the wall, a few surprisingly practical. In the days that followed, the team combined and refined three of them into one prototype—a quick win after weeks of spinning their wheels.
Research shows classic brainstorming, with strict rules against early criticism and structure that balances freedom with focus, outpaces conventional meetings in both idea quantity and downstream results. The key is combining playful energy and an open environment with the discipline of time limits and clear, well-scoped challenges.
Next time you’re tempted to call another normal meeting, try reframing the problem as a sharp, focused challenge and set playful, encouraging ground rules from the start. Post the rules somewhere everyone can see, number your ideas, and keep energy flowing with a quick warm-up. Grab anything around—spoons, socks, shampoo bottles—and use them as inspiration or props. You’ll be amazed at how quickly quantity turns into quality, and how your team unlocks hidden creativity. Let it run for just an hour; you’ll probably look forward to the next one.
What You'll Achieve
You’ll increase your team’s creative output and sense of belonging, while building confidence in your ability to generate and combine novel ideas under pressure. Externally, you’ll see more solutions and more engagement from everyone involved.
Run Short, Wild, Rule-Breaking Brainstormers
Pick a focused, upbeat challenge.
Frame your brainstorming problem as a specific, customer- or user-focused question. For example, instead of asking 'How can we make our school better?', try 'How might we help students find their materials faster in between classes?'
Enforce playful, productive rules.
Gather your group and set clear guidelines—no criticism, encourage goofy ideas, aim for quantity, and build on each others’ suggestions. Post these rules visibly or say them aloud before you start.
Number ideas and use physical props.
Write every idea on a shared board or post-it, numbering each one to track volume and encourage creative energy. Bring in real objects, samples, or pictures to stimulate thinking.
Warm up with a quick group exercise.
Start with a fast, non-judgmental group activity—word association, sketching, or another team-building game. This reduces self-consciousness and boosts collaborative energy.
Reflection Questions
- When was the last time my team really played during problem-solving?
- What keeps me from sharing wild ideas in a group?
- Who on my team could help create a more playful spirit?
Personalization Tips
- At work: Organize a lunch brainstorm with your team on a recurring customer complaint.
- At home: With your family, hold a 15-minute Saturday 'crazy ideas' session about a messy kitchen cabinet.
- In a club: Use piles of random objects to spark ideas for your next fundraising event.
The Art of Innovation: Lessons in Creativity from IDEO, America's Leading Design Firm
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.