Retention Over Acquisition—Why Winning Over Current Users Beats Chasing New Ones
When the founders of DogVacay launched their pet-sitting app, they expected pet owners to register and immediately book sitters. Instead, hundreds signed up and then vanished, never completing profiles or contacting hosts. Most marketing teams might have shrugged and started chasing new users. Instead, DogVacay called the first batch of sign-ups, walking them through the app, answering questions, and helping them finish their first booking.
This personal touch wasn’t scalable forever, but it turned hesitant users into loyal customers who felt genuinely cared for. Many then told friends about their positive experience. Later, the company automated follow-ups and offered small bonuses—like discounts for scheduling a second booking or uploading a pet photo. These efforts turned a leaky funnel into a devoted community.
Other companies use similar strategies: Dropbox gives extra storage for finishing a tutorial; Uber re-engages past users with ride credits and personalized emails. Each of these steps is designed not just to win people, but to keep them around, making every new customer more valuable over time.
Behavioral economics research shows that the cost of keeping a customer is far lower than constantly recruiting new ones. Loyalty, trust, and small regular engagements compound, turning scattered buyers into true fans—the foundation for stable, lasting results.
Reach out to your current users with a personal follow-up—see how they’re doing, offer help, and thank them for sticking around; think about what small, exclusive bonus or resource you could offer for continued engagement, and consider setting up a quick guide or welcome message for anyone new. Keep listening closely to suggestions and complaints, acting quickly to turn them into wins for your community. Start with one outreach or extra today and with each interaction, you’re turning casual users into loyal advocates.
What You'll Achieve
See engagement improve, reduce drop-off, and build deeper loyalty—so your organization prospers from repeat users, word of mouth, and stronger long-term results, while you experience greater satisfaction by building real relationships.
Strengthen Loyalty by Deepening the User Experience
Regularly engage with your existing users or customers.
Send personalized follow-ups, check in after sign-ups, and offer support or insider tips. Even a simple check-in email or call can make a big difference.
Offer meaningful value-adds tied to continued use.
Introduce loyalty bonuses, exclusive features, or educational resources that reward users for sticking around, like giving extra storage after a tutorial or exclusive content for active members.
Teach users how to get the most out of your service.
Help them overcome barriers through onboarding walkthroughs, quick tours, or small incentives for providing feedback or completing key actions.
Monitor satisfaction and act quickly on feedback.
Set up systems to capture user frustrations and act fast to resolve them, turning potential churn into new loyalty.
Reflection Questions
- How often do I check in with the people already using my service or products?
- What might keep an existing user from leaving, and how do I provide that?
- Which simple bonus or meaningful teaching could increase my users' loyalty?
- How fast do I react to user feedback today—and how could I do better?
Personalization Tips
- An afterschool program keeps families coming back by offering returning kids a special badge, plus a personal note to their parents.
- A freelance coach checks in with clients after each session and shares a resource specific to their last conversation.
- A musician runs a special livestream Q&A just for repeat listeners, deepening the community and boosting word of mouth.
Growth Hacker Marketing: A Primer on the Future of PR, Marketing, and Advertising
Ready to Take Action?
Get the Mentorist app and turn insights like these into daily habits.